The MacBook Air was virtually the standard recommendation for anyone looking for a thin and light laptop. But with the new Surface Laptop, Microsoft is finally trying to change that. So today, we're putting these laptops through the paces in our lab, from a two-day battery test that simulates work tasks and video calls, to using our robotic arm to test performance in real-world applications like the browser and Photoshop. We also measured the displays, speakers, webcams, and microphones of these devices. So, by the end of the video, you'll know whether the MacBook Air remains the better laptop or whether the Surface is actually worth the extra $300
that Microsoft is asking for it. Let's find out. This episode is sponsored by Zapier, which allows you to go from simply chatting with your favorite LLMs to actually taking action with them. After all, with Zapier MCP you can connect AI to over 9,000 apps. So instead of having to switch between a bunch of different tools to set up a project here at PhoneBuff, I can just use one in Claude. For example, I might say, "Create a project in Notion for the final Galaxy S battery test, pull our historical battery ratings for S 21- S 26 from Google Sheets, check if there have been any significant battery software updates since launch, and add those as well.
Create a task in ClickUp for our researcher to run the test, then send a Slack message to our editor to shoot a v-roll when the testing begins." Claude will then perform these actions in all these programs on my behalf, which frees me up for other things. If you're a little hesitant about letting AI do something for you, I understand. That's why I also like that Zapier NGP gives you fine-grained control over exactly what the AI can and can't do, because, you know, there's no reason for us why Claude should be able to delete one of our Google Sheets with years of battery test ratings. That would be very bad. Therefore, we simply do not grant him such permission.
You can check out what I created in Zapier and learn more at the first link below. So, starting with displays, Surface has two main advantages. First, it has a touchscreen, while the current MacBook Air still doesn't. And secondly, it also has a higher refresh rate of 120 Hz. So, whenever you scroll through web pages, move windows, or do anything that involves rapid movement, it feels noticeably smoother than on the MacBook's 60Hz display. Now, when it comes to brightness, Surface has the edge again. We measured an average of 517 nits across five points, while the MacBook averaged around 460 nits. Of course brightness alone only gives a
partial picture. Therefore, we also tested reflectivity. And here the MacBook has the advantage, as it suppresses glare much better, while the Surface is almost like a mirror in comparison. We also tried to measure it more objectively: under the same lighting conditions, direct glare was only 18% of what you see on the white MacBook screen, compared to 43% on the Surface. This means that if you 're in a bright room with a lot of glare or outside, the glare will make the Surface screen a little harder to read, even though it's technically brighter. But the good news for the Surface is that in the dark it is no
worse than the MacBook, as both show a result of less than one nit. However, when it comes to color accuracy, there is a difference: the MacBook is slightly more accurate in both the sRGB and P3 spaces. Most people probably won't notice this, but if you work with color professionally and don't want to calibrate after the fact, then the MacBook has the advantage. So, overall, when it comes to displays, if you need a more responsive experience, like fast touch response or a 120Hz refresh rate, then the Surface wins. But if visibility in bright environments and slightly better color accuracy are more important to you, the MacBook wins. But in any case, you will need speakers that match these
displays. And before we get to the measurements, just listen to these two sound systems for yourself. But how much you can hear it depends on what you're listening to at the moment. So let's also look at the data, where the Surface is clearly the louder of the two. However, the sound quality is mixed: the Surface produces more sound in the range from 200 Hz to 1600 Hz, so it copes better with the lower midrange frequencies, where most vocal parts sound. But after 1600 Hz, the MacBook takes over. And that's what adds more presence and detail. What surprised me the most here was the bass: although neither laptop is capable of producing deep sound due to the small size of the speakers, Apple seems to generate harmonics to create the
bass effect. When you turn up the volume and the beat comes on, you hear a punchy force on the MacBook that you do n't hear on the Surface. So, the main conclusion is this. If you need a louder speaker and more voluminous vocals, then Surface will provide you with that. But if you want a speaker system that sounds a little cleaner and has better bass, then the MacBook has the edge. Of course, the speakers don't matter much if the battery is dead. So next we'll check how long these two laptops can actually last. Let's start by browsing web pages, which, as you can see, is not too difficult. We just take turns opening the same sites and scrolling through them. After 2 hours, the MacBook Air had a slight advantage,
retaining about 81% of the charge versus 78% for the Surface. So, a small 3-point advantage for the MacBook, and we move on to performance. This time we are actually switching between many applications. We work in Microsoft Word and Excel, copy and paste text between them, type on the keyboard, and all this with music from Spotify in the background. This is as close as possible to how you actually use a laptop in real life. After 2 hours, the Surface showed a significantly better result, five points ahead of the competitor before the start of the Zoom test.
This test is simple again: we try to simulate a real video call using a cardboard image of my head at work; After 30 minutes, the Surface increased its lead again, with 57% charge versus 49% for the MacBook. This is not at all the result I expected. I thought the gap would be smaller, but we'll see how they do in 16 hours of standby time. The good news is that both laptops performed admirably, losing only 3 percentage points each. Regarding Disney Plus, it's worth noting that we always calibrate displays and speakers to the same level. So everything will be fair and just, as far as we can control it. And I expect the Surface to further increase the gap because, unlike the MacBook, which
is locked at 60Hz, the Surface display can downscale to 24Hz to match the video frame rate, which should theoretically give it an advantage in battery life. And after 2 hours, it could make a significant difference: the Surface's charge dropped by only 18 percentage points compared to a 24-point drop in the MacBook. This means that before the final test in Adobe Premiere, where we will work until the laptops run out of battery, the Surface has a 14-point advantage. But the difference with Premiere is that, unlike all previous tests, this one actually loads the chipsets. Whereas up until this point, all other tasks were relatively easy. And here the situation changes dramatically. While the Surface was significantly more efficient during light workloads,
the MacBook proved to be much more efficient during heavy workloads, almost completely eliminating the Surface's advantage, and as a result, both laptops shut down with a difference of only 5 minutes. Technically, the Surface won, but considering we're talking about over 20 hours of total testing, I think 5 minutes is well within the margin of error. So I would call it more of a draw. And it really all depends on how you use your laptop. If you mostly do light tasks like web browsing, office work, or video calls, then Surface definitely has the advantage. But if you're doing something complex, like photo or video editing, then the MacBook will probably last longer. But there is one thing that is undeniable, no matter what you say, and that is the
charging speed. Using the included power adapter, the MacBook was able to charge to 46% in 30 minutes, while the Surface was only able to charge to 33%. Well, it's time for what we've been waiting for: we used a robot-controlled mouse and keyboard to test these laptops in real-world applications. And while we wait for each laptop to load, let's quickly go through the specs, where we've selected the lowest price for each model. So you get the Snapdragon X2 Plus in the Surface and the base M5 chip in the MacBook. And at least when it comes to booting the OS, the MacBook was about 3 seconds faster. So, the first real test we do is web surfing, where we
load videos, 3D models, and maps on our local site, and even perform calculations to create a graph. Well, both laptops showed the same result, completing the work in exactly 18 seconds. Next, we load a 500-page document into Microsoft Word. And, surprisingly, Microsoft's hardware turned out to be slower: the MacBook managed almost twice as fast. But I'm curious to see what happens when unpacking files, where each laptop has to unpack the same 6- gigabyte file. And, guys, the difference is quite noticeable. The MacBook did it instantly, in less than 10 seconds, while the Surface took almost four times as long. And this was consistent in all our attempts. But maybe unzipping files is
just slower on Windows. So let's see what happens in Photoshop, where we not only run the program, but also edit the same 50-megapixel RAW image. First, we perform a spot correction, and then we use the "Finger" tool with a brush. We select the cone object in the background, and then finally apply a content-aware fill. And this time the results are much closer. The MacBook still finished first by 26 seconds, with the Surface only 6 seconds behind this time. But now it's time for the biggest test in Adobe Premiere. The first thing we do is download the program, and then create a project. We import two identical clips to each laptop, then apply
color correction to the longer clip. We add a warp stabilizer to the shorter clip. We render, as if for a preview, and then export the entire sequence. So, many tasks were put before these laptops in a row, and the difference is simply amazing. The MacBook completed the task in 1 minute and 46 seconds, while the Surface took almost twice as long to complete the same set of tasks -3 minutes and 19 seconds. So, Surface performance is not the best yet. And unfortunately, things don't get any better in Blender, where the Surface took 27 seconds longer to render the same 1080p image. And the most interesting thing is that all the applications we tested ran natively on the Surface arm64 architecture. So the broadcast penalty doesn't really apply here.
Although in Cyberpunk, where the broadcast takes place, the MacBook copes faster: it loads the game in 39 seconds, while the Surface needs 48 seconds to fully launch. Of course, it was just a game download. This doesn't say anything about the gameplay itself. So, we ran the test on ultra settings, and despite working through the streaming layer, the Surface held up decently, delivering the same 18 frames per second as the MacBook. Of course, none of these laptops are designed for heavy AAA games. You'll probably need something else for such tasks, but you can achieve acceptable frame rates with frame generation, especially if you lower the graphics quality. But overall, in terms of
performance, the MacBook is the undisputed winner. Of course, we haven't tested every program, and your experience may vary depending on what software you use. However, among the tested applications, the MacBook was either as good as the Surface or, in many cases, significantly ahead of it. By the way, speaking of image quality, we also tested the webcams using our realistic silicone head. Here the difference was quite significant under different lighting conditions: in low light, bright light, and in scenes with high dynamic range, the MacBook consistently showed better results.
Skin tones looked more natural, the image was noticeably sharper, and there was less noise overall, especially when looking closely at the subject's face. So if you spend a lot of time on video calls, for example at work, you'll look much better on a MacBook. As for how you'll sound- listen to it for yourself. After two long years of research and development, the PhoneBuff camera test is finally here. After two long years of research and development, the PhoneBuff camera test is finally here. The MacBook picks up a little more background air conditioner noise, but the voice itself sounds fuller and more natural, so it was closer to our reference microphone during frequency analysis.
Both sound good, but again I prefer the MacBook. Where the Surface is ahead is in ports: like the MacBook, you have two USB-C ports and a headphone jack, but in addition you get a full-size USB-A port. But the trade-off for this is that Microsoft had to use a wedge-shaped design, where the back of the laptop is slightly thicker to accommodate this port. So, overall, the MacBook ends up being thinner, as well as lighter. And when it comes to the actual speed of these USB-C ports, the advantage is again on the MacBook's side. During our 50GB file transfer test, the MacBook was able to complete the transfer in just 13 seconds, compared to 43 seconds on the Surface. Of course, if you don't have external drives capable of supporting such speeds, the difference
obviously won't be that dramatic. And the good news is that, at least when it comes to Wi-Fi, there really isn't any difference between the two. Both support Wi-Fi 7 and provide virtually identical results. As for the rest of the hardware, both laptops have large tactile trackpads that you can click anywhere. Although the MacBook has a slightly wider screen than the Surface. And the MacBook's hinge opening angle is slightly larger: it opens at 134°, compared to 133° on the Surface. So, really, the difference is not that big. So, we've looked at a bunch of data, and yet there are two things we have n't even talked about yet.
The first is the price, as at the time of this video, the Surface costs $300 more than the MacBook. The second thing is the OS and application compatibility, because while ARM on Windows has certainly come a long way, it is still not as advanced as Apple silicon on macOS. So if you're leaning towards a Surface, I'd just make sure the apps you use every day are fully supported here. As for who wins, looking at the Surface, I see a more responsive display, louder speakers, and a slight advantage in interfaces. But when I look at the MacBook, it has an edge over the Surface in almost everything else, including price. Obviously, you already know what you want.
Our job is just to provide you with data, so let me know what you think is a better deal. Anyway, that's all I wanted to say in this video. Thanks for watching, and as always, see you in the next episode.