It has been 83 days since Canada's closest ally and largest trading partner imposed 50% tariffs on about $20 billion worth of Canadian goods. And during this time, the situation escalated quite quickly. Trump ordered every Canadian company doing business with America to immediately move to the United States, banned imports of Canadian alcohol, dairy products, and motorcycles, threatened to block aircraft manufacturer Bombardier from entering the U.S. market before deciding he would actually take good care of its workers, and even renamed a lake just in case. Now Canada was not sitting idly by. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau responded with mirror tariffs on $27.6 billion worth of American goods, and
the mood in the north deteriorated just as quickly: 41% of Canadians now see the US as an enemy, up 15 points from just over a year ago. All of this is happening along a border that Trump has called an artificially drawn line, as if someone drew it with a ruler, just a straight line across the top of the country, which is somewhat ironic since his trade war is making that line more real than it has been in decades. But despite all the headlines, about three-quarters of Canadian goods still cross that line without paying a cent in duty, meaning it's a targeted battle and not something resembling a closed border, at least for now. So, what would happen if this border were closed completely? This
sounds like a pretty silly question, and if you go that far, it probably is. But the answer to it shows how dependent Canada truly is on its neighbor and how healthy its economy is beneath all the noise. It also forces all other US allies to watch closely what will happen when two economies so intertwined try to sever ties. Before we begin, there is one rather important caveat. The US midterm elections just happened and Democrats gained control of the House and Senate, which means a lot of what we're going to talk about could change, or at least slow down, now that Congress has a lot more influence over how this trade war plays out. But the economic fundamentals of it all remain the same as they were last week, and that's what we're
interested in here. So, as always, we have some important questions to answer. Who really needs whom more in Canada -US relations? What is the real state of the Canadian economy during the trade war? And finally, could Canada close its southern border and become economically independent if it had to? Have you ever come to the gym and realized right before you started your workout that your headphones were dead? I don't know if it's just me, but it seems like this happens almost every time. This is where the sponsor of this video-Raycon-comes to the rescue. Everyday Earbuds Classics from Raycon are premium quality at an affordable price. I've only had them for 3 months, but I've been using them almost
every day since I bought them: at the gym, running errands, or just working from home. I choose them over other headphones because they allow me to disconnect from everything and focus on what I'm listening to. They hold a charge for up to 32 hours, and every 10 minutes of charging gives me 90 minutes of use, which saves me when I forget to charge them. Honestly, at this point they have become an integral part of my daily routine. Black Friday is coming soon, and this year the decision is easy to make, because you can get a discount of up to 50 % on the entire range. Follow the link in the description or visit buyraycon.com/economicsexplained to get up to 50% off during
Raycon's Black Friday sale. This video is sponsored by Raycon. So to understand what closing this border would mean, we first need to realize how much passes through it. Canada and the United States have one of the largest trading relationships in the world : last year, the United States spent about $454 billion on Canadian goods and services, selling about the same amount in the other direction. However, for Canada, these relationships are almost everything. Trade in goods and services accounts for about two-thirds of the country's GDP, while exports alone account for about a third, and most of these exports go to just one place. About seven out of every $10 that Canada earns from exporting goods comes from one customer-the United
States. This is quite unusual for a developed economy. If a business received 70% of its revenue from a single client, accountants would have plenty to be nervous about, and that's exactly the situation Canada has been in for decades. Let's be fair: these relations were even more one-sided before. The U.S. share of Canadian goods exports has fallen from more than three-quarters to about 72%, the lowest level in forty years. But the basic deal has always been simple. The world's largest consumer market is right next door, with no oceans in between, with a common language and similar legal systems. Therefore, Canada built its economy around supplying the United States, rather than competing with them. The best example of this is oil.
Canada produces approximately 5 million barrels per day and exports about 4 million. These oil exports are worth about 140 billion Canadian dollars per year, and about 90% of it goes to the United States. This is partly because the vast majority of Canada's oil pipelines are directed south. Less than a fifth reaches a port, from where the oil can be shipped to other countries. So for a significant portion of Canadian oil, infrastructure effectively chooses the buyer. This also helps explain one strange detail. Canada exports millions of barrels a day while importing hundreds of thousands, mostly from the U.S., because oil production in one part of Canada does not guarantee easy transportation to a
refinery in another. The system is built around trade with your neighbor. In addition, there is the automotive industry. The two countries' automotive industries are so closely integrated that a single part can cross the border multiple times before making it into a finished car, meaning that duties can be paid over and over again for the same part. A great example of this is the deadbolt -that little metal loop that your car's door lock latches onto. Made by a company in Windsor, Ontario, it crosses the border four times. It starts as Michigan steel, is formed in Windsor, heat treated in Brampton, coated in Michigan, inspected again in Windsor, and finally shipped to an assembly plant in the
US. It is this level of integration that makes Canada so vulnerable at this point. American tariffs are hitting its most important industries. Let's take steel and aluminum. US tariffs on these industries reach 50%. For the automotive industry, it is 25% with the threat of further increase. Lumber and copper have also been caught in the crossfire, and a 50% markup on billions of dollars of other goods is adding to the overall bill. Since the major tariffs took effect, exports of goods to the US have fallen sharply. Exports of cars and parts have fallen nearly 6%, and Stellantis has told the union it is considering selling or closing its Brampton assembly plant.
Canada's retaliation is not free either. The countermeasures are raising prices for Canadian consumers, and some analysts estimate that the U.S. mirror response dollar for dollar has returned Canada's effective tariff on U.S. goods to levels seen in the late 1970s. The problem is that it is almost impossible to simultaneously influence key US states, hurt American manufacturers, and protect Canadian households. But even now, most Canadian exports still cross the border duty-free. After the August escalation, only a fraction of Canadian goods are subject to any U.S. tariffs. So, the harm is real, but it is also quite targeted, which raises a very obvious question.
What is at stake here for the US? What do they get from this relationship? Trump's position is clear. America doesn't need Canada, but Canada needs America. And the trade data partially confirms his words, but not completely. Canadian oil accounts for about two-thirds of U.S. crude oil imports, and refineries in the U.S. Midwest are specifically tuned to handle the heavy oil that Canada produces. This means that to replace it, the refineries themselves would have to be re-equipped . And the moment chosen for this was extremely unfortunate. After a significant reduction in supplies following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the US Strategic Petroleum Reserve is still well below its 2022 level, despite partial replenishment, making
replacing Canadian supplies particularly difficult in the short term. Canada also supplies about 80% of America's potassium imports, and potassium is a fertilizer that has no real substitute. In addition, Canada has dominant shares in American imports of aluminum, uranium, and electricity, and Trump himself has acknowledged how dependent the United States is on Canadian aluminum. What makes this even more telling is what happened when the US imposed new tariffs. They made exceptions for energy, potassium, fish, and critical minerals, which is a pretty clear indicator of where Washington believes its leverage lies, and where the dependency works the other way around. Canada is also one of America's largest buyers. It is the
main export market for more than half of the US states and the largest market for American manufactured goods. In recent years, border states like Montana have sent nearly 50% of their exports north, and for North Dakota, the figure exceeds 80%. There is also the trade deficit, which is the focus of the White House's complaints. The US does have a goods trade deficit with Canada, but when you factor in the services surplus, the overall gap narrows to just under $30 billion, which is quite modest for a relationship worth almost $900 billion. It is also worth looking at what this deficit consists of. Last year, the US imported significantly more energy from Canada than it sold back to it, and if you exclude energy, by most estimates the US has a trade
surplus with Canada. So the deficit that the White House keeps pointing out is mostly because the US is buying the oil it needs. And the interesting thing is that the US doesn't just burn this oil. They make money from recycling it. American refineries convert Canadian crude oil into products like gasoline and diesel fuel, then sell them domestically and abroad. Some even makes its way back to Canada, which gets most of its imported fuel from the US. It's a bit like a tailor complaining that he spends more at the fabric store than the store owner spends on suits. So, both countries benefit from this relationship, just not to the same extent. They sell roughly the same amount to each other, but for the US, exports to
Canada are less than 1.5% of GDP, while for Canada, exports to the US are about 19% of the entire economy. The US could, of course, replace most of the goods it buys from Canada, but it would be expensive. Fuel prices in the Midwest would rise, fertilizer would become more expensive for farmers, and aluminum would become more expensive for manufacturers. For some resources, this would take years, as entirely new supply chains would have to be built. But it would be much harder for Canada to replace its largest buyer. Now Canada has a few trump cards up its sleeve, but it doesn't really want to use them. When the US warned Ottawa not to use energy resources as leverage, Prime Minister Carney
rejected this premise categorically. Last year, Ontario tried to impose a surcharge on electricity exports to three border states, but repealed it the very next day. The leverage is real, but Canada needs revenues from oil and electricity sales just as much as the US needs these supplies. And this is the fundamental problem with any resource-based influence. When you depend on the income from selling something, turning down a buyer hurts you too . The question then becomes: who will be able to last longer? Most Canadians support Canada's own tariffs, and two- thirds say they are in favor of them even if prices rise. Meanwhile, most Americans oppose Trump's tariffs on Canada, and with Congress
now in Democratic hands, a larger economy isn't necessarily more patient, which brings us to the second question. How strong is Canada's economy on its own? At first glance, things don't look so bad. The first quarter was stable, with growth of 0.8% observed in the second quarter. Exports have surged: car and light truck sales have increased by 27% year-on-year, and corporate profits have risen sharply, driven largely by energy companies . But, as always, things are not as simple as they seem. Car exports were recovering after production disruptions during the winter. Meanwhile, household incomes were supported by a one-off increase in the GST credit, and the World Cup provided a small boost
to sectors such as professional sports, transport and broadcasting. This is all well and good for one quarter, but it's not something that can be repeated every year. If we set aside these situational factors, the underlying dynamics were much weaker. This is most noticeable in the labor market. Canada lost a combined 100,000 jobs in August and September, erasing most of the year's gains. Today, the unemployment rate is approximately 6.5% and continues to rise. But the sectors most affected turned out to be completely different from what one might have expected. The biggest losses have been in education, health care and social security, partly due to cuts in international student permits-a reminder that not all of
Canada's problems are currently coming from Washington. Moreover, the challenges do not affect the entire country equally. Quebec and Ontario are shedding jobs, while Alberta, an oil province, is one of the few where they are being created thanks to stable oil prices and new pipeline capacity. A weakening labor market would normally give the Bank of Canada a reason to cut interest rates, but inflation is pulling in the other direction. By mid- year, it had exceeded 3% due to Canadian tariffs on American imports and higher gasoline prices. And on October 28, the bank even raised rates to 2.5%, warning that persistently high energy costs could spread to the entire economy. That's the problem. Supporting growth
risks fueling inflation, while fighting inflation risks weakening growth. A slowdown in immigration also occurred, and this reversal was striking. Last year we warned that reducing immigration could ease pressure on housing and public services, but it would also mean fewer workers, customers and costs. In the long term, this is probably right, but in the short term it will be painful, and that is exactly what we are seeing now. After population growth of over 3% in 2023, largely driven by temporary residents, the government has slowed sharply, reducing the target for permanent residents from 500,000 to 395,000, with plans for further cuts.
Meanwhile, the number of temporary residents has decreased by about 7%. The result is that population growth has virtually stopped, and fewer people mean fewer consumers, renters, and shoppers, which is not a good time when your biggest customer is already buying less. Now that the housing market is finally correcting, prices are expected to continue to fall, especially for condominiums in Ontario and British Columbia, but the long-term problem has not gone away. Since the late 1990s, labor productivity in Canada has fallen by about a quarter compared to the United States. For a while, Canada masked this with increased working hours and high commodity prices, but after the collapse in
oil prices in 2015, GDP per capita also began to lag behind. Almost two decades ago, Canadian businesses invested about 90 cents per employee for every dollar invested by their American counterparts. Today, it's about 55 cents, meaning Canadian workers have less equipment, less technology, and less capital for each hour they work. Over time, this gap leads to lower productivity and lower wages. And to top it all off, the government doesn't have significant resources to help. The federal deficit is approximately C$65 billion in the current fiscal year, and debt service costs are rising rapidly. So Canada is facing the biggest trade shock in a generation, in a much weaker position than the headlines suggest. So, with
an economy that's weaker than it looks and its biggest customer turning away, could Canada actually close its southern border and go its own way? Well, no one has seriously modeled a complete shutdown, which in itself gives a good idea of how impractical it is. You would cut off about 70% of merchandise exports, about 90% of crude oil exports, and the automotive industry, whose parts cross the border multiple times for a single car. A more realistic version of this question: what would happen if Canada lost preferential access to the US market, meaning the free trade agreement completely collapsed. And this is not such a crazy hypothesis anymore. CUSMA, the trade agreement that replaced NAFTA, contains a provision for
review every six years. If either party declines to confirm the extension of the agreement during this review, it remains in effect until 2036, but is subject to annual joint review thereafter, as a lease that the landlord may not renew. And during the first review this July, the US did just that, refusing to renew the agreement in its current form, even though Canada and Mexico supported a full extension, meaning that the worst-case scenario is now possible every 12 months . Deloitte modeled what would happen if CUSMA were to completely collapse, and their analysis found that Canada's real GDP would be about 1.6% lower over a decade, with significant job losses each year. Some sectors will be completely
devastated: electronics will fall by 21%, and the automotive industry will suffer even more. Deloitte described the overall impact as serious but not catastrophic, although for individual industries the losses could be just that. Oxford Economics modeled what a complete collapse would look like and estimated that over the next decade, Canada's economy would lose about 1% of its output, compared to less than half a percent for the US. But in pure money terms, the US actually loses more, about $1 trillion, but its economy is much larger to spread those losses. Now, what about diversification? Carney's stated goal is to double non-US exports within a decade, and on paper it's working. Last year, non-US
exports reached a record high, and their share of total exports became the highest in the last four decades. The problem is what exactly stimulates it. A significant share of the growth in exports to countries outside the US has come from the UK, mainly due to gold and other precious metals, and shipping bullion to London does not exactly open up new markets for Canadian industry. And then there is China. Canada lowered tariffs on Chinese electric cars, and China responded by lowering tariffs on Canadian canola, but Trump threatened punitive tariffs in return. When trade talks with the US
collapsed in August, Carney said that one of America's final demands was veto power over Canada's trade deals with other countries. The US denies making any last-minute demands, but in any case, diversification itself has become a subject of conflict. Canada has signed a number of new economic and security agreements with countries outside the US, but the scale of what needs to be done is staggering. Doubling exports to countries outside the United States would require new growth of about 5% of GDP, roughly equal to the combined output of Canada's entire mining, quarrying, oil and gas industries. And at this time, Canada's ports are a "bottleneck
." Vancouver, Canada's busiest container port, has fallen to the bottom of the World Bank's Container Port Performance Index, ranking 375th out of about 400 ports in the world. This is not exactly where you want to be when your plan is based entirely on increasing shipment volumes. In fact, even under Deloitte's best-case diversification scenario, GDP would grow significantly less over the decade than Canada would lose without preferential access to the U.S. market. So, if diversification alone is not enough, what is needed to make Canada significantly less dependent? For starters, Canada needs to improve its pipelines and ports. The expansion of the Trans Mountain system has already ensured that
about two-thirds of the tankers loaded at the Vancouver terminal are sent to Asia, and a new pipeline from Alberta to the British Columbia coast, called Pacific Link, was declared a national project last month, but it is still in its early stages and far from completion. And even if it is built, the share of crude oil exports to countries outside the US would only increase from about 15% to 23%, which is better than nothing, but still a long way from independence. Next-improving trade between the provinces of Canada themselves. Removing internal trade barriers could boost Canada's GDP by anywhere from 1% to 7%, which is a pretty wide range, but in any case, it's money that's currently being lost.
There is real progress now, as provinces have begun to recognize each other's product standards, and most now allow direct shipments of alcohol to consumers between provinces. The problem, however, is how much still needs to be untangled. Each province has its own rules, and there are so many conflicting regulations that one professor at the University of Ottawa is now using AI to review them and identify discrepancies. And what he finds is, to put it mildly, a bit absurd. For example, Ontario is the only province that requires public restrooms to have U- shaped seats, a rule that matches American standards, but limits the range of suppliers from which
Ontario can purchase them. This is a bit of a funny example, but it proves that barriers exist, and even finding them is a huge job. Third, and most importantly, is productivity and investment. Remember, Canadian companies invest about 55 cents per employee for every dollar that American firms spend, and this gap limits their ability to compete outside the US. If Canadian businesses don't cut it, diversification will only mean trying to sell less competitive products to more distant customers. So, is it possible to do this? Could Canada completely close its border? Not without enormous costs for both countries, but especially for Canada. Although Canada could become much less dependent. Trump may have done more
to spur domestic trade reform and the construction of new pipelines than countless political reports. Whether this urgency will persist after a new Congress, annual CUSMA reviews, or simply because of easing pressure remains to be seen. Canada is not the only US ally caught in the crossfire. We've already created an entire video about how Europe found itself caught between the Gulf War and the tariff wall in the West. If you are interested, you can click on the link on the screen now. Thanks for watching, friend. Goodbye.