Bubble tea is the hottest food and beverage category of the modern age and has been growing non-stop across the West since the early 2010s. Unlike past fads like frozen yogurt and cupcakes, bubble tea has established its staying power as both a product and business. Bubble tea was introduced to the US in the90s by chains like Quickly and Tapioca Express. But they suffered pioneering costs as their growth was restricted to the predominantly Asian communities of St. Gabriel, Sunset, and Flushing. Boba in this era was a cheap1 to $2 drink made from powdered mixes and non-dairy creamer. Because flavors were identical from chain to chain, these first movers relied on low prices and cross-ell to survive. Bubble tea was an
entry-level low margin turnkey retail business, and the only way anyone really made money back then was through franchising. While things remained primitive in the west, the industry progressed in the east. Beverages universally have been a low barrier industry. Real estate requirements are low. Product costs are mostly water and prepackaged commodities, and labor is simple as anyone can boil water and pour milk. These factors make beverage-based businesses easy to scale. Starbucks, Duncan, and Jamba Juice had shown through the '90s how to snowball momentum from a single store into a sprawling franchise empire. New brands like Gonga and Happyle Lemon emerged across Asia. Looking to replicate that success in boba, they brewed teas, used
real milk, and expanded toppings to make higher quality distinct drinks and diverse menus. This helped broaden appeal, push higher prices, and drive greater consumption. By the 2010s, competition had intensified across China and Taiwan, with each new entrant adding their own spin. Some turned bubble tea into extravagant desserts with cheese foam, cream, candies, and nuts, and others followed the path of third-wave coffee, elevating the drink with fresh fruit, photogenic layers, natural sweeteners, organic milks, and store ambiance. These winning concepts and trends started in Asia and then slowly trickled to the US. While Western companies conventionally look east, bubble tea is the rare industry where
it's east going west. China and Taiwan have become saturated with brands and their profits have slowed. But as legacy coffee giants have stagnated as more Asians have immigrated to America and Asian-American culture has grown, bubble tea in the US has become a gold rush. Americans possess the highest disposable income in the world, have demonstrated their interest in boba, and yet have the lowest familiarity with the product. Asian brands have invested millions of dollars into US franchising and even rewritten their own history for better branding and marketing. Independents have created their own concepts which compete on product and originality. What
was once a low margin niche business in the9s is now a high margin, high cash flow business that has caught the eye of Starbucks and even fast food chains. As the birthplace of boba in the US and home to the largest population of Asian-Americans in the country, there are more bubble tea shops in LA than anywhere else. Los Angeles represents the forefront as consumption and standards are years ahead compared to any other city in the West. Innovation is a prerequisite to survival. While Asian chains have attempted to dominate Southern California, their franchises never seem to last under the neverending onslaught of new entrance. In this modern NBA exclusive, we're going on the ground to understand the hidden
economics of bubble tea and what it takes to win in this world from the lens of three different shops. Los Angeles is massive and every neighborhood is its own market. While retail businesses are conventionally spread out in American urban design, this stretch of land in West LA is an anomaly. Sandwiched between UCLA and Santa Monica, these three blocks are prime real estate with unmatched foot traffic and clientele. Some of the city's most popular food and beverage concepts are all clustered here on Sautel. It takes 6 minutes to walk from one end to the other. And along the way, customers get to choose from 40 restaurants, three cafes, eight petisseries, two bars, and five bubble tea shops. Competition here is literally one step away. The density makes
business here a true zero sum game in that any customer that gets bubble tea at one of the five boba shops results in a direct loss of income for the other four. With such material opportunity cost, how do you differentiate and carve out market share on Sautel? This is a challenge that Hannah has faced since opening 7 Miles Teab. She entered the industry 5 years ago as a franchisee for one of Taiwan's hottest chains. Coming from China, she knew the business potential for Boba, but was content as a newbie, tapping into the knowledge and resources of an established brand. But that relationship turned frosty as she lacked the autonomy as a franchisee and the brand lacked flexibility as a
franchiser. When things slowed, Hannah came up with three new drinks to reignite sales. But it took many months of back and forth with HQ to get approval. What Hannah saw as necessary adaptation and local insight, her franchiser saw as meddling. They would rather keep scaling, even if that meant fitting square pegs into round holes than to slow down. Ironically, Hannah's three drinks became the chain's best sellers, and this gave her the belief that she could create and capture more value going her own way. She used her developed expertise and connections to try an MVP in a smaller market. The first seven miles opened up in Artisia and served as a two-yearong proving ground before moving on to Sautel. And having gone from franchise to
independent, Hannah knew firsthand what she could compete on. The advantage of having a very small brand of uh having it born in LA is the flexibility of knowing your customer and design the right product for the customer you're serving for. This brand is not born in Asia. We're trying to study the people here. It's really scary because when you are coming from a big brand, you definitely have the brand name. But what people don't know is they always have more negotiating power. When they are coming to their inventories, they probably have the first access to the best inventories. Whereas for us, we have to spend time researching and getting it to our hands. That's from the ingredients perspective. coming from a
big brand. If you are one of the franchises, then you are enjoying the marketing force behind that brand and you're enjoying a lot of people who are working on logistics, not just the shops. Some of the really bigger brands or some of the mega players probably have the technology to have the cups scanned and have all the ingredients going into their cups. Whereas we have to train our people, memorize the recipe and it takes a lot of training also takes a lot of mistakes for them to make a right drinks. The efforts that you're trying to put in your employees are very different. They probably can focus on service from their day one. We have to focus on making the drink right from day one. If an employee is good at
making drinks and not good at service, we cannot fire him because we need him to make the right drink. Calvin enjoy. For some brands, you can hire the people that are really, really friendly to customers. You can hire people with that personality. You don't have to train the people in the back with as much efforts as we are putting in. So, we're definitely very scared and also we do know that it comes a long way. Like the impact of that probably won't show on day one. It's probably going to show on in two years, you know. So, how do we climb down the mountain? To Hannah, market saturation in LA is only a matter of time. There's so many players in her home country that competing on brand is feudal. In China,
every brand has a mascot. Every cup is decorated, and no one is memorable. In her own Chinese words, Hannah isn't trying to dingpie. She's not looking to establish 7 Miles as a brand. Her shops by design lack positioning, and she admits it's difficult to even explain 7 Miles as a concept since they serve everything. Fruit teas, dessert drinks, classic milk tea, and trendy Asian flavors all under the broad umbrella of bubble tea. We are not trying to label oursel with fresh fruits, organic products, developing a space where people can socialize. We're trying to be a boat shop people can rely on. They think our products are consistent and we're trying
to make it a brand that's not offering the best service, but are comfortable for people. If you want to be quick, you can come in and pick it up. If you want to not socialize, you can order on kiosk. If you prefer the social, we give it to you. So, we're trying to be a brand that's your neighborhood brand. For Hannah, the only strategy worth pursuing is product. 5 years ago, ingredient quality and menu creativity was enough to differentiate. Her theory is that people in LA nowadays know Boba so well that they already have preconceived desires and expectations when they walk in. The challenge is not just offering a drink that will exceed those expectations. It's also having a
menu that will guide customers to the right choice, even if they're not able to express what it is that they really want. If we were to go open a new pity shop here, you think you're comparing with both shops that already existed on the street and you think that if I offer the same product, are you going to gain the same amount of customer? The answer is no. Because if you're offering the same product at the same price point, they'll tend to go to the shops that they already know in order for you to stand out in that competition is that you have to offer better product at better price point and they're not just going to tell right away. It's very subjective for a business owner. Like if I uh I taste it
one by one, I have two in my hands, I can taste the difference. But if you were asking them to taste it today and taste it tomorrow, they might not notice it. So it takes a lot for a customer to actually change what they're used to. You know, it's not just one visit. There's a Chinese term, it's called, right? It's a point where they come in with a certain need and you fill up that need. So I think when you are offering products, you're actually offering service. We're not trying to offer the best peach fruit tea. We're trying to see what does the customer actually want when they want a fruit tea. You know, maybe they're trying to quench the thirst. Maybe they're trying to have a
lot of flavors in this cup. Maybe they're trying to find something creamy. Maybe they're just trying to have a lot of ingredients. Like, I want boba. I want everything in this cup. I want a lot of things to chew on. I think for Bati the fun thing about this business is it's so diversified and it's so big that there can be a lot of things happening in that one cup of tea. We're not trying to have a very extensive menu where he has to make very complicated decisions. We're trying to have very simplified menu so it makes us a more reliable shop. Yet this product focus is a privilege in itself. With so much foot traffic right outside the door, the challenge for seven miles is conversion, not awareness. A shop in a weaker location
could not afford such a reductive lens on strategy. Yet, while drinks are the public facing competitive advantage of any bubble tea shop, the real moat is in the supply chain. 70% of the bubble tea shops that are currently existing in this market are trying to buy local. They are trying to use whatever source are available to them in the most convenient way in the smallest business unit that you can have. However, if you're trying to use the same ingredients all the time, the same ingredients as the rest of the sixy shops on your street, how do you create a single cup of products that's surprising to customers? If you're using
the same OT, same old flavors, how do you have enough creativity to make sure your customer are exciting for this cup? How can you differ from anyone else? If you are using the same ingredients, then it only relies on your creativity and that's very unreliable. You probably can have one cup of tea that's successful because of your creativity, but you can't have a whole line of products that's, you know, more tasty or like that's just better taste than other people, right? If you're using the same ingredients, you're very it's very hard for you to compete because the ingredients are what make up the drinks and the drinks in turn are what make or break the business. What exactly you use and who you get them
from are closely guarded secrets for every owner in this world. For this reason, we weren't allowed to film any supplies in their kitchen as that would be giving away her competitive advantage. Hannah's bubbly personality is a fascinating contrast with her pragmatic character. She views the industry with such stoicism that she openly shares these hard truths with uncanny nonchalants. Business is rational. Money is the only objective. Chains and independence all have their right to belong. And there's no value in morality. If you're in oati business, you more or less have to face the decision of whether I should franchise or not. There is a lot of advantage of franchise
except es especially if you're a new beginner. However, you need to see that the franchise market is very different from the retail market. They are trying to make money out of volume, out of scale. They are able to game up as they build up the volume and scale. So, you need to see behind their intention to be able to figure out whether sometimes you are sharing the same piece of pie. You know, there are certain conflicts that are not going to be resolved as a franchisee and franchiser and you need to face them and you need to acknowledge them. There's no right or wrong. It's part of the game. As you have a lot of experience with the industry, you're going to see the big picture of it at some point. And it's
very helpful to see the big picture to know that where what you're competing with, especially for a small brand like someone else. In the franchise business, usually you're asked to pay a royalty. You make a initial payment to the brand and those are the money that's clear to you. However, when you are a franchisee, you are able to tell a lot of the cost your inventories does go to the brand and that's very normal. It makes 100% sense that take they're taking that money. However, what if your inventory cost is triple the market cost? What if your shipping cost is triple the marketing cost? What if your profit is completely eaten up by that? You need to
understand that your initial investment is part of it. Your royalty is part of it. Your ingredients, your inventory is part of it. Also, at the same time, they're trying to build up their skills. So, they're trying to open as many as they can open. Whereas, you are trying to be the only one in your area, right? So, there are a lot of aspect that goes behind the franchising. Whereas the smaller brand, you don't need to face that. But on the other hand, you face the power of how they are going to nail you with their brand, right? How they're going to nail you with their R&D, how they're going to nail you with their marketing, with all the forces that they have behind them. So, it's not an easy
game for anyone. I'm trying to say that people are in different games. People are in here for different profit. And you need to understand that and you need to have that perspective whatever business decision that you're going for. 7M Tea Lab on Sautell grosses on average $90,000 a month for an annual revenue of $1.08 million. Meanwhile, their store in Artisia grosses half of that, $45,000 a month for an annual revenue of $540,000. Location is the only difference between the two stores and demonstrates just how important that variable is in retail. As a beverageonly business, the average order size sits at just $9.
Yet store level operating margins sit at 30%, some of the highest ever covered on modern MBA in retail. Yet the density of competition on Sautel and the non-brand focus means that Hannah isn't able to push pricing. 7 Miles is positioned in the middle of the market and she's sensitive about raising prices in what is ultimately a volume business. Despite the eyepopping numbers, Hannah is a realist. In her mind, disruption, just like saturation, is inevitable. She can't predict how long 7 mi will last. But despite the fragility, she's just opened store number three in Chino. In the world of bubble tea, scale is mandatory. The more shops you open, the more negotiating power you get with
suppliers, which not only lower costs and increase profits, but also widens ingredient possibilities. Your initial supply chain and drinks are how you penetrate the market, but scale is how you strengthen your business. This is why Hannah, even as an independent, is focused on expanding to as many locations as possible while she has the momentum. Just like the Asian brands and the legacy coffee and smoothie chains that came decades before bubble tea. When we're looking at industry, you know, there's a period where you're industry start and it's growing until it reaches maturity and it starts to decline.
Feel like the LA Bati market it's on the way reaching the maturity. We see a lot of consolidation like we see a lot of brands that are not doing so well. they will die because bigger brands are merging and the market itself is merging into those few survivors and then it's going to reach the maturity of it. There used to be a period where a bub shop pops up, people will come. We're no longer in that era and I feel like whoever is going to come into this business needs to know that people are no longer excited about it as it used to be. You need to be almost very mature in this business in order to survive. It is a business with volume unfortunately. So I always say that for beginners coming
in, you probably need three stores to have your own distribution channel to have ingredients that are more superior than the local market. You probably need 10 shops to have the top-notch products. You probably need 15 to have certain technologies. So, it's no longer a market for beginners. It's a market for those who are already established. It's hitting the maturity. And I only say that for California. I don't say that for a lot of other states. Some of them, I think you still have opportunities to make people exciting for the brand. And then you have time to figure out, but for California, unfortunately, I don't think it's that market anymore. There's
currently six or seven bati shops on the street that we're on. And we are currently performing relatively well. The market is not going to outbeat the growth of the number of boba tea shops. So the people who are drinking it is not going to outbeat the growth of how many bob shops there are going to be, you know. So we are at the end of the day trying to split the same pie. We feel like if we are bringing better products, then we're taking some customer over and there will be shops that are going to not survive anymore. unfortunately and they are going to be replaced by the ones who are doing better than them.
It's a business of scale. You have to have a certain volume for it to grow to find better ingredient to build your own distribution channel for you to be able to build a better team. So it comes down to a lot of perspective but it is a business that you have to reinvest in. maybe on opening new shops, maybe on distribution channels, maybe on your warehousing, maybe on I don't know, maybe on promoting a new manager, but it is not like we keep the profit of this month. We haven't kept a penny from the first day. It has all been moving to, you know, upgrade your game. Unfortunately, that's how this business is. You really have to keep up upgrading your game otherwise you won't survive in the competitions.
Minutes away is Oddwan Out, one of Hannah's four direct competitors on Sautell. They're on the corner and while they're within the same three blocks as 7 mi, they enjoy none of the foot traffic that 7 mi gets on the main street. Despite their inferior location, Odd One Out is one of LA's most expensive bubble tea shops. And like Hannah, Ron and Pat are new players in this industry. They only started 3 years ago, but had extensive prior experience in food and beverage. Back in 2012, Ron had founded Food Panda in Taiwan, which before Uber's billion dollar acquisition this year was the leading food delivery app on the island. Pat, on the other hand, cut his teeth helping CPK and Domino's
grow their pizza empires across APAC. The two crossed paths during a business meeting and kept in touch over the years. And the longer each of them worked in Asia, the harder it was to not see the inevitable rise of bubble tea. Yet, Ron and Pat were neither boba enthusiasts or consumers. We kind of viewed it, you know, in college, you start drinking beer, right? And then once you grow up a little older, you start drinking wine. And then as you get more sophisticated, you start drinking cocktails and eventually just to straight up spirits. There's like an evolution of taste as you grow in age.
We did see that bubble tea was something that was growing globally. We saw that there was a big trend going on in China with some brands that were really taking over and becoming kind of like the next Starbucks. We saw that when we came to the US there were kind of like this resurgence. We thought that we can do something a little different because everything that we did see was pretty much a cookie cutter of one brand versus the next. The drinks were the same, the format was the same. While right now bubble tea is mainly seen as a product, but if you look into coffee space, there's brands that have done really well such as Starbucks. Most of the product was quite singular. When we did
our research in Taiwan, in Asia, in the United States, it's the same thing from the '8s. And we just didn't really see much elevation of ingredients. It's still the same suppliers. All the suppliers were all the same. While Hannah came at it top down with outcome first, Ron and Pat approached product from the bottoms up. We really do focus on the quality of the tea. And tea is very similar to like the wine world or whiskey world where you can get a $5 bottle of wine at CVS or you can go to a wine retailer and get something for a,000 or $10,000. Maybe not everybody can taste the difference, but there definitely is a difference. And we believe tea falls in the same category
where there's just a huge variety. And every single bubble tea store will tell you they use premium teas. There's nobody who's going to say they don't. I don't think it's true because most bubble teas work with just the same generic distributors or suppliers that present you a menu of all these tees and most of these tees are from very lowcost tea countries such as maybe Vietnam and they grind it down to like dust which is the cheapest kind and then they add tons of sugar or milk whatever condensers to kind of mask the flavors. So how we do things very differently is number one we worked with a tea master in Taiwan to just introduce us to tea. So, one of the youngest tea masters who really got us
to really open our eyes to see, okay, teas can come in many different forms, different qualities. And we started to basically source our favorite teas from all these different small batch farmers in Taiwan and even custom roasting our teas based to the specifications that we like. In the tea world, there are these like collectives, right? And what they do is they source tea from this region and they just collect and they label it all under one thing. They might be collecting it all in Taiwan and they label it Taiwanese tea. You know, it's really interesting when you work with the larger distributors. They have everything, right? They have the sugar, they have the boba, they have the cups.
It's like a one-stop shop. There's pros and cons of that. Obviously, it's easier to operate. But, you know, on the downside, everyone has than the same kind of tea. When you buy ulong tea, you just get one type. But, you know, ulong te's are quite unique. There's so many different styles that we thought would be really interesting to introduce to our customers. Their north star was to revamp bubble tea into something sophisticated where the unrivaled ingredient quality, flavor originality, and unique preparation would lead to an unassalable mode in product and brand. But to achieve this, Ron and Pat needed to learn to create drinks, build their own supply chain, and acquire knowledge
at a depth that few could ever replicate. And there was no better place to do this than Taiwan. Everything we needed to know about bubble tea was born in Taiwan and still thriving in Taiwan. So it was an easy decision to set up shop in Taiwan. Also labor costs in Taiwan is much lower as well. So we can get all this wealth of knowledge for a lower price than if we were to get set up here in the US from the get- go. It was also a proof of concept of our first store. We were able to get an amazing team with lots of industry experience. Tea masters to our mixologists to uh our R&D team to people who do marketing in the space. A lot of successful brands in Taiwan, they have to first be successful in Taiwan. They
first have to compete in the Taiwanese market and if they catch enough attention from franchises maybe in America, then they could sell their franchise to any franchisee that wants to open shop in America. So, we kind of like did it the opposite way, right? We built the MVP for Taiwan, but we've always had a focus of trying to do things in the United States. Since me and Pat got together, decided to do this. So, the day we launched our store in Taiwan, it took 564 days. And it's a long time to prepare for a bubble tea store to launch where most people at least in Taiwan and I would suspect here in the US would maybe spend 3 months.
They initially hired 15 mixologists, bartenders who had the hard skills, develop pallets and mastery over sugars and liquids and gave them complete freedom to develop non-alcoholic boba recipes. The winning 10 recipes incorporated unorthodox ingredients like coffee bean husk, fermented vinegar, and tea steeped in coconut water. But as impressive as these drinks were, they were unscalable. Ron and Pat then brought on boba experts to streamline and scale these recipes. It was a novel marriage of two worlds. The creativity, sophistication, and originality of mixology, applied to the ordinary bubble tea, and then backed by the latest innovations and mature business processes from the industry. But even after all this R&D, it was not a
straight shot to success. Achieving product market fit is as much luck as it is merit. And the best business is often the simplest one. When we wanted to market our brand, because Mixology is in our core, we're telling customers that Mixologist did create our drinks. But that was very confusing to them because they didn't know if we were a bar. What we realized is that people never really have an occasion or behavior to have mocktails. The big turning point was when we realized our staff that what they were drinking every single day was actually not the mocktail like drinks. It was actually our red ulong milk tea with the cream foam on top. And we decided to sell that drink as the
employees favorite. That's what we named it. And there was this competition in Taiwan that happens milk tea festival competition. We submitted that drink to that competition and won first place in our category. And we started to really heavily advertise that in front of our store. So when people walked by our store, we had this big sign that said, "We are the champions of the Taiwan Milk Tea Festival." And that's how people started to come in and we drove a lot of traffic. Yeah. There's this quote that I love to say, but you know, everything has already been done before. You just need to make it a little bit better. What we were originally doing, our starting point was doing something completely not
even existed. And that was very difficult. And all we had to do was make our basic product better. And we were actually using the best milk. We were handcrafting all of our sugars and our tea leaves were all independent sourced really unique tea flavors and that in itself as the component was already better than what was available in Taiwan. Most people come for our milk tea because it's something that they're familiar with. So, it's just like in the pizza world. Let's say if you take Domino's as an example of Pizza Hut, they'll always introduce these crazy flavors, these weekly or monthly flavors, but at the end of the day, 80% of the sales are still going to come with the pepperoni or the cheese pizza.
People will come in for our milk tea. Today, it's it's at least probably 70% of our sales. Even though very few people actually know about the milk tea festival or how significant this competition really is in the industry, this employee creation turned contest winner has become Oddwan Out's calling card. It's an official label of credibility, an overseas rubber stamp of authenticity, and a badge of honor that no American competitor would ever possess. Thus, while 7 Miles defines quality through emotional outcomes, Odd One Out defines quality through more objective terms. Most bubble tea, what they do is large batches of brews, they steep it in a large vat with hot water, 20, 30 minutes, whatever it may take,
and they just filter it out and put it in a vat. But what happens to that tea over time is the flavor changes because of temperature and time. And that also limits them with how many teas they can offer. Most bubble teas they have four or five at most. Black tea, green tea, one ulong and maybe one something else. And we actually carry seven, eight, nine different tees. We have to portion every single tea differently. We have to grind it also differently depending on the type of tea. If it's a rolled tea or if it's a bow curl tea. But while 7 miles's MVP in Artisia carried over to Sautel, Oddwin Out's momentum in Taiwan did not translate overseas. In Taiwan, our shop for the first few months didn't deform so well. But me and
Pat still made that decision to go to the US and try it out because just because something doesn't work in Taiwan does not mean that it doesn't work outside of Taiwan. So, a large part of this is about product market fit. Sautel over here is quite competitive. There is a lot of people who drink boba on a day-to-day basis. Because Sautel is so thriving, it's really hard to get a prime location. The closest one that we can find where our shop is right now is actually on Olympic off of Sautel. Not even a 2-minute walk from the main area, but still very hidden. So, we basically get no foot traffic. The UCLA students call it the Plaza of Death simply because not many businesses survive in
this plaza that we've selected. Again, we're not in the best location here in Sautell. And yes, our prices are expensive versus our competitors. There's no doubt about it. But that's because we put in so much into our product, into our service, into everything that we do. Odd1 Out grosses on average $77,000 a month for an annual revenue of $924,000. Their operating margins sit above 30% given the cheaper rent in an inferior location. While the average drink at 7 Miles costs $5.74, the average drink at Odd One Out is 12%
more expensive at $647. Their award-winning Champion Milk Tea starts at $8, not including tapioca and makes up the majority of sales. Higher prices mean greater order sizes as a customer spends on average $14 in a single transaction at Odd One Out. like Seven Miles, Ron and Pat are now harnessing their current momentum to scale with store number two underway in Santa Monica. Compared to Hannah, Ron and Pat are more upbeat about the future and longevity of their concept. Right now, at the stage of the business that what we're at, customer experience and product is the most important thing. When it comes in the FnB world, especially, people are paying something cuz they want to enjoy it. As businesses
do scale, they kind of lose focus on that. Even if you have the best marketing in the world, the best Instagram in the world, they come in, they don't like it, they're not going to tell their friends about it, they're never going to come back. Our business right now is an 80% returning customer business simply because we believe that we have the best product in the area possibly in America, maybe in the world, and we're going to continue on that and hopefully be able to scale like those other big businesses without losing that product focus of our brand. Most neighborhoods in LA are nowhere close to these levels of traffic, clientele, and consumption of Sautel. 7 mi in Ottawa out by extension are outliers as they represent the top 1% in
volume and earnings. Both shops have been open for barely a year on these three blocks and are already rolling out location number two or location number three. Yet, the bubble tea business looks very different when inserted into an ordinary non-destination neighborhood. 30 minutes away in Echo Park is Heii, a boba shop that's ingrained itself into this neighborhood for the past 6 years. While 7 Miles and Oddwan Out wield product and social media to keep the sizzle going as long as possible, Hei plays a different game in a slower, more residential market. While atmosphere is an afterthought for most boba shops, Chris has made it a competitive advantage that's just as compelling as product.
I grew up in the San Gabriel Valley, so I was there like in middle school when Taiwanese like bubble milk tea just hit the scene and it was just purely like this new trend kind of like fro yo and you would just uh have black tea and boba. And then over the last decade as it was kind of in parallel with specialty coffee shops, you really started to see some really cool different recipes and layering of smoothies or the colorfulness of fruit teas and just like packaging it in almost like a dessert beverage which was kind of siloed in predominant Asian markets. It further increased competition. One less barrier of entry cuz the startup cost isn't that high.
It's like who can make something that's more and more outlandish in terms of the drink experience. I think the market drives a lot of boba or bubble tea shops as something that's cheapened or like fast food buy one get one free. And I wanted to provide the alternate experience where you get really high quality stuff by having things made inhouse. And I think some of that was lost or absent from the tea house culture and just because it's more service towards maybe like the kid or more focus on volume and maybe owners getting into it just purely from a profit perspective. Chris sees Heihei as a contemporary tea house where people can relax and just so happens to serve bubble tea. While it's not clear if the LA market is mature
enough to understand the nuances between a tea house and a boba shop, this strategy has given Heii a longevity that few boba shops have ever achieved. Drinks are what pull customers in. Boba is the main draw on the menu. Yet, the ambiance is what gets them coming back. In Chris's mind, product is the most common mode, but it's also a fleeting advantage. On the other hand, physical space and community are permanent assets that outlast hype and taste. Heii is not just for lounging. On certain days, they'll host game nights, food pop-ups, cookie decorating parties, live music, and knitting workshops that are open to
all. Echo Park will never match Sautel and traffic, but within the confines of this neighborhood, Heii is a social destination as much as a regular drink institution for locals and transplants alike. While 7 Miles and Odd One Out are like most boba shops in that they open late and close late, Heii opens early and closes early every day by 3 hours, so customers can stop in for coffee in the morning and then boba after work. I felt that the cafe culture was becoming more of like a remote work space and library type of setting. And so I wanted to create a different type of gathering space that you can meet people through not just a common table but like through installations. We always had the
intention of having a larger space so that we can activate it through a lot of free programming from pop-ups to workshops, listening parties, food popups, and then from a space perspective to create lounge seating more like campfire seating. So you're lower to the floor and it's just more natural to engage other people. And through these experiences and installations built around the space as organic ways to bump into someone or have a way to ice break versus sitting next to someone and hoping someone drops a pencil and you like bump into them like a movie or something like that. A lot of times you go into a place and you just want to just feel seen. So that's what we are trying to inject back into community.
Thank you. When you come in, you're acknowledged. You feel at home. And one of our best markers is if you don't have any plans on a Friday, and it's not because you don't have any friends, you just don't have anybody that called you or set up plans, you can come here and you'll feel right at home. Either you are recognized or are open bar setup and seating. It's just easy to chill by yourself and enjoy all the action that's happening. As a former consultant, Chris sees the world in abstracts. Demand is sequential with physical nourishment as the primary need and community as a secondary driver. While 7 Miles leans more into desserts and Otto and Out leans more into tea, Heii leans into coffee. For
Chris, it's not an eitheror between tea and coffee. And surging beverage chains like Dutch Bros are a source of inspiration for him in both product and business. It's easiest to compare yourself against a very similar brand. So, if I was a boba shop or a tea house, my direct competition would be a boba shop and a tea house. But really, you're competing for mouths. Basically, if someone is thirsty, they're going to go for a place where you can consume a beverage. So, I think of it really based off of your mood, like what type of mood you're in, based off of your thirst profile. And I think it's easy to think that okay boba shops my direct competition is with them. But I've
always had the question of if you are just serving drinks why not increase the menu that also you can serve every pallet. Thank you. Enjoy. We devised our menu with one drink for one mood. So to hit the derty really fun kind of signature beverages. Those are all kind of smoothie or more decadent uh aesthetic kind of focused. And then we have a section that's just for people who are really thirsty. Like if you're thirsty, you're looking for something light, something citrusy, fruit based. And so that's how we created that section. And so from an operational perspective to have a small number of SKUs, it's more effective and efficient for us, but also allows us to focus and
be known for certain types of drinks. Before opening in 2018, Chris had been stuck behind a desk in corporate America. He had the idea for Heihei and knew he could iterate on decor and atmosphere after opening, but there was no way he could get away with improvising product on the fly. But without any experience in bubble tea or retail, he had no idea how to make drinks, develop recipes, operate equipment, manage staff, or run a shop. Chris was in his 30s when he traded in his six-f figureure salary and Ivy League colleagues for minimum wage kitchen work and teenage co-workers.
Coming from a business background, I wasn't just going to hire like a chef or some type of subject matter expert. If I'm going to start a brand, I can't rely on someone to be the subject matter expert. So, aside from just enjoying drinks and just being a huge fan of mixology and coffee and tea, can I actually make it? I started doing what everyone would do, just googling recipes and just testing it at home, sharing it with friends. But I knew I had to take the next step and get some real ground zero knowledge. And so during that time, I tried to moonlight and part-time at, you know, the top tea houses at the time, just try to see like what's the actual numbers and uh would I be cool
and be humble enough to be able to open and close a store, mop floors, clean bathrooms, like beyond just like saying hi to people and serving drinks. When stuff breaks, would I be able to fix it? These are the types of drinks that I love to make. Do I know how to make the components of it from brewing teas to cooking boba? And I was in consulting for eight years prior to that. And I don't believe in any experience as lost experience. So I really pulled my strengths and what I was trained to do, which is going into businesses, analyzing them, learning them.
He went to Meat Fresh and learned how to cook taro, jelly, and ube. He went to Half and learned how to prepare tapioca, syrups, and teas. He went to a Japanese petissery where he flipped crepes and made fillings. And he ended at Phil's Coffee where he absorbed how they managed teams, handled service, trained baristas, and generated atmosphere. In 18 months, Chris had lifted and shifted the strengths and recipes from all these different businesses to form his own understanding of retail ingredients, which he then directly applied to create all the drinks and processes that make Heihei what it is today.
Heii grosses on average $30,000 a month for an annual revenue of $360,000. Topline comparisons are tricky as Heii has been around for 6 years in a quieter neighborhood while 7 Miles and Oddwin Out are in their first year in a Yepy destination. All the hype and buzzes on their side as LA's two newest independent boba shops. Will customers still regard Otwan Out's champion drinks as highly as they do today in half a decade? How much of 7 Miles's popularity is due to location and novelty? Would either of these shops still be grossing as much 6 years from now as they do today? And what is the greatest form of success? Is it the shop that lasts, or is it the shop that peaks the fastest
and highest in the shortest amount of time? Hei's store operating margin sits at 20%. Chris spends more on labor as his staff must be able to make drinks in the open bar and talk to customers. It's a contrast to the predominantly college student population that makes up most of the staff at Oddwan Out and 7 Miles. And because he just has one store, it's hard for Chris to lower costs without economies of scale. Yet, it's clear that atmosphere is a crucial element of the Heii concept. Chris had attempted a second store at a nearby shopping mall with the same drink menu, but struggled to get things off the ground with the limited space and the grab-and-go mindset of the mall clientele. Heii's
drinks are priced the highest of the three with an average price of $6.70. 60% of the sales are for bubble tea with the other 40% being the coffee or fruit-based beverages and customers spend on average $11 per order. Chris controls his product costs by maintaining the leanest possible menu. Heii's menu is made up of 20 drinks compared to Oddwin Outs 29 and 7 miles is 42. We're situated where there's a lot of bars, lounges, restaurants, and we seem to be the pregame spot. So, we have a lot of couples that come sometimes their first dates. They come to Heihei first, grab a drink, chill out, and then go to
their next destination. Growing up, I would never take a date to go to a boba shop unless, you know, my parents were still like driving me around. Um and also just last year we had engagement proposal here um because their first date was at Heihei. So it was awesome to be a part of that. Life is a school and everyone pays tuition. In the world of bubble tea, supply chain is everything. The more ingredients you pick, where you get them from, and how you use them is the difference between life or death. Seven Miles, Odd One Out, and Heihei demonstrate that there's many ways to pay this tuition. You can be like
Hannah. You can tap into an established leader, learn all the ins and outs, and then lift and shift once you're ready to strike out on your own. This path is the fastest but definitive and requires capital. Alternatively, you can be like Ron and Pat. You can invest the time that no one else is willing to do to master the fundamentals and to uncover the secrets. This path is the hardest, but if you pull it off, you end up with the deepest understanding, the widest moat, and the greatest payoff. Or you can be like Chris. You can walk in the shadow of those that came before you. Piece together your own take by replicating what you see and then hone an edge by pulling in a different bet. And as the bubble tea industry
demonstrates, there's no one right way. And the path you ultimately choose is a decision that is as personal as it is economic. Okay, I got a hei.