Claire Saffitz Shares a Butternut Squash Pie Recipe Perfect for Thanksgiving

Claire Saffitz Shares a Butternut Squash Pie Recipe Perfect for Thanksgiving

Claire Saffitz demonstrates how to make a butternut squash pie baked on a sheet pan, a fall and Thanksgiving dessert that serves a crowd. The recipe is a variation on pumpkin pie, with a squash-based filling she has long wanted to try.

The Thanksgiving Pie You Didn’t Know Needed | Claire Saffitz. | Transcript:

Hello everyone. I'm Claire Saffitz. Welcome to my home kitchen. Today I have a recipe for fall, as well as Thanksgiving. Today I'll show you how to make a butternut squash pie on a baking sheet. Я буду готувати його у своїй формі для випікання Made In. Convenient to serve. You can feed a lot of people. I'll show you a version with butternut squash, which is a kind of variation on pumpkin pie. have something to tell you: I've had an idea for a long time that I really want to try for the filling for this pie. But I've been really busy lately, I'm due to submit a book manuscript soon, and I haven't had a chance to fully proofread it. So we'll test it on the go and see if it

works. I tested it in stages. I just have n't put it all together yet. So today I'm taking butternut squash, which is very easy to find. And the reason I'm using it is because I want to try this idea with decorative cake topping. And this probably only works with butternut squash. So, for the ingredients, we'll start with my butter shortcrust pastry. I made one and a half times more dough because for a pie on a baking sheet, you need to cover a larger area. Here it is, I have it here. It's ready. You can see me making it 100,000 times in other episodes of Dessert Person. Of course, we have butternut squash. It will go into the filling and for decoration. For the rest of the filling, we

will need 5 tbsp. l. unsalted butter, 4 eggs, 3/4 cup heavy cream, a little light brown sugar, and vanilla. I also have a mixture of warm spices. I put them all in one bowl because I don't have a million little bowls like that. Here we have salt , cinnamon, ground ginger, allspice, ground nutmeg, and cloves. It is not necessary to use all of this. You can add cardamom if you like it. Any spice mix will do. And for decoration, I have granulated sugar and a couple of tablespoons of butter. So, this will go towards the decoration. Now for the special equipment-my baking sheet, of course. This is a Made In porcelain baking dish.

It is ideal for such pies. If you don't have one, you can use a 13x9 inch pan. I also have an immersion blender, which will be needed for grinding the filling, since we're not starting with a puree. We start with a whole pumpkin. I also have a few more things: a saucepan, a rolling pin, and a couple of other standard kitchen items. That's all. Before I get to the recipe, I want to thank our friends at Made In for sponsoring this issue. At home, I use the full line of Made In cookware: ceramic, stainless steel , carbon steel, cast iron, and porcelain cookware. Today I'm cooking in my baking dish. It was developed in collaboration with chef Nancy Silverton. I like it because it is porcelain and resistant to temperature changes. It can be put

in the freezer, oven and directly on the table. Sometimes I just use it as a tray because it looks so pretty. Made In cookware is used in the best professional kitchens in the country, in over 4,000 establishments. And this is a wonderful gift. If you want to learn more about porcelain or other tableware, follow the link in the description and save on your order. Now let's get back to the recipe. So, I roll out the dough. It sat at room temperature for a few minutes to soften a bit. When I made it, I gave it a rectangular shape because the dough tries to keep the shape it had while cooling when you roll it out. So we make a rectangle, and I cooled it in the shape of a rectangle.

We're going to roll it out on both sides, and the pie dough should be about three millimeters thick. When I roll out pie dough, I don't use too much flour. You should not pour so much flour that it covers the dough with a thick layer. That wouldn't be good, but I pour enough to cover the surface well and it doesn't stick. And I don't hesitate to add more if needed. I like to keep the dough moving and flipping it frequently to keep both sides from sticking while rolling. And I also like to change the direction of the swing as I go. I need it to be about 5 centimeters longer and wider, 5 centimeters in each direction, than the baking dish. I'll have a little extra dough because we're going to make a

decorative border. It will go along the bottom of the sides with a slight overlap. Now I'll do the same movement, winding it onto a rolling pin. Then we take a baking dish. I'll try to place it as evenly centered as possible. And I'm promoting it. Important point: when you line any baking or pie dish with dough, do not stretch it to the bottom. You should let it lie down on its own, as if to cushion it, but not stretch it. Because any stretching, and we've already done a good job with it during the rolling, will lead to cracks. As you can see, I have a small allowance.

I'll trim off a little bit of the excess and then tuck the edges in. So now I'm going to go around the edge and tuck this excess in. Well, now I have a finished edge on the baking sheet. Now I'm going to make a figured edge, usually on pie pans with wide sides I make wide snaps. This time I'll make them a little smaller. Here you would normally use your knuckle or thumb to make a large wave, but for now I'll just use the tip of my finger to make a smaller pattern.

The point of such an edge is that you take this thick layer of dough and increase the surface area so that it bakes well. It bakes completely and you won't have thick, raw layers of dough. But of course we want it to look beautiful. Now it needs to be cooled. We've done a good job with the dough, activating the gluten, so now it needs to rest and cool down, because it's warmed up. So, I'll take it away. Usually a freezer would be best. I don't have room in the freezer, so I'll put it in the refrigerator and while it cools, I'll work on the filling. For this recipe, I have a huge butternut squash. Let's see how much it weighs.

Almost one and a half kilograms. He is huge So, I will have some product left over, but overall this recipe uses one large butternut squash. So the first thing I want to do, and I think people have questions about how to do this, is some winter squash can be hard, and sometimes the knife just gets stuck. So with a butternut squash I start by cutting off the stem, rocking the squash sometimes helps push the knife through. Then I separate the neck from the base. Here they look almost the same, but you usually have a thinner neck and a spherical base. So I'm separating them here and now I'm going to clean the neck. That's why I use butternut squash-because it has a neck that doesn't have any seeds in it. So you have this thick, solid piece of

pumpkin, and I'm going to make some nice slices out of it, which will be my filling. The basic steps for the filling, for pumpkin in general, are that I'll make these caramelized, like candied slices for the top from the neck, and then use the base and whatever's left of the neck to make the filling So we'll make both components at the same time, and the biggest question for me is that I know that each component is delicious on its own, so I don't question the very idea of combining them together. For me, the question is when to

combine them? Should I combine them before baking or after? This is the biggest question. Okay, now that I have the base, oh, excuse me, the neck of my pumpkin, I've cleaned it. And you may have to go through the peeler a second time to make sure the skin is completely removed. Я розрізаю її навпіл вздовж. This creates a flat surface and now we can cut it. So I'll make these little crescents. And I will cut them into thin slices. It is not necessary to cut too thinly, like paper. Usually, if I'm slicing something thin, I think, okay, I'll throw it on the mandolin. Але мускатний гарбуз занадто твердий для мандоліни. So I'll just do it by hand and cut it OK. I need about 400-425 grams of chopped pumpkin. So now I need a pound of

diced pumpkin for the filling, because that was for the top. I have part of the pumpkin neck left. It was a huge butternut squash, so I had more than enough of it. So, here I have the bottom part of it. I could clean it, but it's a little too small. So I'll just cut the peel in a circle. OK. This is a pound of my diced-I don't know what to call it-shredded pumpkin. Тепер почну готувати начинку. Of course, it needs to be prepared. I'll start by sautéing, essentially cooking on the stove.

Stir occasionally until the pumpkin is slightly browned and soft. Now I'll show you what a pumpkin looks like. He began to soften. It's a little browned on the bottom. And he became very soft. This is exactly what we need Now I'll add the cream and spices. Return to the stove briefly to bring the mixture to a boil. That's all, and then we'll blend it. And then we'll wait a bit. I don't want to add eggs, because one of the important secrets to making a cream pie is hot cream in a hot pan. Cook over medium heat and simply mix everything. You need to dissolve the sugar and evaporate some of the excess moisture from the pumpkin. It's been simmering for a minute or two, now let's blend it.

Let me taste the filling. My God, this is so delicious. I'll move on to the top, but first I need to put the pan in the oven. I'll take it now. I have two pieces of foil. You can use stronger foil. I have dried beans as a filling for the pie, and a large baking sheet because oil drips can occur. I take a pie form. Press the foil to the bottom. The idea is to make it heavier, otherwise the dough will rise too much. Yes, we are laying out the load for the pie. I like to press it down and distribute it in the corners. And now we're going to bake it. So, my oven is at 400 degrees. We're going to bake this pretty hot, and that's usually the

first stage of baking with foil-about 25 minutes, until the edges start to brown Then we remove the foil and put it back. I'm going to lower the temperature to 325, and that's what we're going to use for the filling as well. This will be baked a second time without covering. We want the bottom to brown well. And then the third time, with filling. So we need to start this process. I'm sending this into the oven at 400 degrees Okay, while it's baking, I'll move on to the filling. I'm not sure yet what we're going to do here. We're figuring it out.

My cake baked with the baking weight for about 20 minutes. I can already smell it, so I think it's almost ready and I want to get to work on the toppings. When you candi something, you cook it in sugar, like in a concentrated sugar solution, and all the water in the dish is replaced with sugar, giving it an incredible texture I did something similar with butternut squash in another recipe and it turns out extremely delicious in sugar, so I'm going to try making something similar. I'll make wet caramel. Wet caramel means the sugar is first dissolved in water, so I add a cup of sugar. Not all of this sugar will end up in the cake, but we need a certain amount of it for the candiing process. A little water to dissolve everything.

Now I'm going to cook this until it's caramelized. I also have two tablespoons of butter and my pumpkin, so let's move everything over here. And at some point I'll take the cake out of the oven and remove the baking load. I think it's best to do it now so you don't have to -it's always risky to make caramel and do something else at the same time, so let me just take the cake out and open it. OK. Wow, wow, wow. It is heavy. And now I'm going to lower the oven temperature to 325 degrees. First, bake at a high temperature to let the dough rise, but once you remove the lid, you shouldn't keep it in high heat, because now the

entire surface is exposed, and if you overdo it, the moisture will evaporate quickly, the dough will shrink, and cracks will appear, so it 's better to bake the second stage at a slightly lower temperature. So, we take out the baking load; That's why I use two layers of foil -you don't want it to tear. This is incredibly annoying. We're going to bake this until the bottom is nice and golden brown. Good. Now let's get back to caramel. I just stirred gently over medium heat to dissolve the sugar, and it boiled, forming a syrup, so I stopped stirring and just waited.

I'm going to boil this and brush the sugar crystals off the sides of the saucepan with a pastry brush, and we're going to cook this until it starts to caramelize. Here we have a very rich dark caramel. She is almost ready. Reduce the heat to a minimum. Now I add the butter. And then I add water. I actually dissolve it into a very thick syrup. I'll also add a pinch of salt and a little vanilla So now we have concentrated sugar syrup. Add the slices and bring it all to a boil. The pumpkin will become soft and release some juice, so it will eventually be completely submerged in the liquid.

We'll cook them like this until they're soft and have absorbed all the syrup, becoming translucent. They will look like candied fruits. This will be very tasty. And now it's time to get back to the filling. I transferred my stuffing into this casserole dish. I'll heat it up again on the stove, add the eggs, and we'll time everything so that it pours perfectly into the pie, because it's already been baking for almost 20 minutes without a load. And he looks very good. So we'll wait. I want the bottom to be a little more golden. The main question of the day: should you add the candied pumpkin before baking or after?

Це насправді залежить від густини начинки. I think they should be added later. And partly I think so, because they won't be ready anyway. Although that's not entirely true, because I have something I cooked yesterday, so I protested. And so I could use them as a topping for a pie. Here are my sugared slices. I think it would be better if we put them in later. Maybe while they're hot, for example, the pie is taken out of the oven hot, and the slices are placed hot too, so that they kind of stick to the filling.

We'll see. I don't know. I don't think this step is necessary, but I would really hate to get to this stage and accidentally roll the eggs. So I'll crack the eggs into a bowl and temper them, which is, I'll add a little bit of the hot mixture, whisk it all together, and then put it back in And we beat everything very well. OK. So, our filling is ready. It looks very good. I'll check the base. Good. Almost ready. When you have an egg filling, like in a custard, you want to put the hot filling on top of the hot base because it will instantly

bake into a thin layer at the base and create an airtight layer. So if you've ever made a pumpkin pie where the filling leaked through a crack in the base and got caught between the base and the pie pan. It still comes out because it bakes eventually, but it's not ideal because the base gets soggy. So it prevents that, which is very good. So we're just waiting for the foundation to be ready. We'll pour it inside. And you see the pumpkin starting to become translucent and soft, which is very interesting. Normally I would pour this into the base while it's still on the rack in the oven, but I want to show you.

Here I have one small part of the base that shrank a little, nothing cracked, which is good, but there was a little shrinkage. So, here I have a foundation that has settled a little. Often I just straighten it back. OK. So, pour the filling. Oh my god, this is going to be so beautiful. This part didn't mix very well. Oh my God. You are now seeing the recipe being tested in real time. Yes, the result will be a little, a little variable. Okay, now I'm just going to smooth this out a little bit.

Now back to the oven. And we will bake until the center starts to jiggle slightly. And I'll start to notice it rising. Oh my god, it's so heavy, you won't believe it. Гм, не знаю, скільки часу це займе. I think less than 30 minutes. OK. The filling is ready. She looks very beautiful. There is a barely noticeable tremor in the center. It bakes very evenly, which I'm happy about And now, being careful not to touch it while it's hot, I'll place the candied pumpkin on top Here, here are these slices. They got ready a little earlier. They're like.look at the color.

They are so beautiful, translucent and radiant. Well, now I'll taste it. Mm. This is, wow. This is really delicious. Okay, I'll start laying out the slices " tiled", I think, at an angle. I was wondering if I should put this in the oven for a couple more minutes, but I think not. I don't even know, friends. Отже, мені вистачило скибочок гарбуза. I imagined they would be a little shinier. We need to let this cool down. I'll transfer it to a cooling rack. Maybe you should boil the syrup a little more and make the glaze.

I guess this isn't exactly the option I had in mind, but I guess that's how it should be. I don't think it's worth spreading the pie filling in "tiles" because you have to spend time laying them out. They will drown. They will float on the surface. Не варто залишати пиріг поза духовкою надовго після того, як ви залили начинку. So it seems like it should be done at the very end. And it looks very nice. So I am quite satisfied with the result. And pumpkin is so delicious. In addition, the baking dish serves as a great serving plate. We'll let it cool a little more, and then we'll cut it.

Okay, the pie could have been a little colder, but the day is coming to an end. The daylight hours and our nanny's work hours are coming to an end. So we'll cut it. I have a feeling. Pumpkin has a wonderful texture. It's a little chewy because it's sugary, but at the same time it's tender. And it cuts beautifully. Of course, I made it in a baking dish, but it could also be made in a tart pan. It would be very nice. Well, let's cut a piece and take a look. I like the proportions. In my opinion, it's just the right ratio of filling and dough.

My God, it looks so delicious. I am delighted. Mm. And one note to myself. I think maybe the spices in the filling are a little too intense. Because they slightly interrupt the taste of the caramelized pumpkin. But it's still very tasty. Mm. Not too sweet. So delicious. This is the kind of recipe I'll probably try again to perfect. Maybe I'll slice the pumpkin thinner or pre-bake the base a little longer Minor changes, but it's very close to the final version. Impressive. But it's not just about showing off. And it's about improving the dish and making it tastier. It was fun and interesting, and I'm sure you didn't know that you can candied pumpkin. So I think it's a great success. I'm glad I tried it.

I hope you found it interesting. It was really exciting. And this can be a real decoration of the Thanksgiving table. I want to thank our friends at Made In for sponsoring this episode. Я обожнюю пекти у цій формі для випікання. Sheet pan pies are a great option for Thanksgiving. They are easy to take with you anywhere and serve right in the form. So, if you want to check out the baking dish and the entire line of porcelain tableware, follow the link in the description below. Made In has a full range of kitchenware. If you've seen many episodes, you've noticed how I use stainless steel and carbon steel. This is all just wonderful. And thank you very much for watching. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and have a great

baking season and Thanksgiving.

More Food Transcript