On May 20, 2026, 43,000 listings in Chicago disappeared. All because Zillow refused to list just… 9 of them. This is a small battle in the war for the housing market. On each side is a housing giant: Zillow, and Compass. And, it seems like Zillow is losing. This war may shape the future of the housing market, altogether. Whether it stays open and searchable, or is controlled by the largest brokerages. But first, what does Zillow do? Imagine you're a real estate agent looking to sell houses. You need buyers, so you turn to Zillow and pay to
connect with people looking to buy a home. When a buyer ends up making a purchase, Zillow takes a cut of your commission. Which can be as high as 40%. This "agent business" alone accounted for roughly two-thirds of Zillow's $2.58 billion in revenue in 2025. So, pretty important. But Zillow doesn't own anything. Not any houses, at least, and not even really the house listings either. The listings, the photos, the property details mostly come from real estate agents and brokerages. Zillow gets access to these listings from regional databases and major
real estate companies. Zillow's entire business depends on having homes for people to browse. The more listings it has, the more buyers it attracts. And the more buyers it attracts, the more valuable it becomes to agents, who bring money. So, what if this access is affected? But before we can get to that, we need to talk about Zillow's opponent: Compass, the real estate brokerage platform, which was trying to do exactly this. Even though Compass started as a single real estate brokerage, it has expanded over the years by acquiring
its rivals. In January 2026, it completed its acquisition of Anywhere Real Estate, the company behind major brands like Coldwell Banker, Sotheby's International Realty, and Corcoran. This gave it access to a network of roughly 340,000 agents, handling around 24% of US home sales by value. And in some cities, its reach can be over 35%. Still, Compass CEO Robert Reffkin has set an ambitious goal to capture 30% of the market in each of the company's top 30 cities. And Compass is using its growing reach to change where homes are listed. Even Redfin, one of Zillow's biggest competitors, agreed to display Compass listings,
potentially adding more than 500,000 homes to its platform. But Compass went further. "On May 8, Compass terminated all direct listing feed agreements with Zillow nationwide, on behalf of itself and every Compass brokerage entity or subsidiary." It ended its direct listing feeds to Zillow across all its brands. Yeah, Zillow wasn't happy about this. In New York, it also offered agents a $1,000 marketing package to move listings away from StreetEasy, Zillow's rental and real estate platform, which attracts around two million visitors a month. So why? Well, on September 22, 2026, the company relaunched Compass.com under the slogan "See It First". This will include properties
that haven't yet reached the open market. The strategy is already drawing attention. Compass.com visits in Chicago were reportedly up 111%. It was clear what Compass was doing, and Zillow, was fairly furious about it. It's called a "private exclusive" strategy. Instead of being on a shared listing database other agents use, or on public sites like Zillow, a private exclusive, is a home for sale Compass only shows to its own agents and their clients. This was part of Compass's three-phase marketing plan. Show homes privately within their network, then list as
"coming soon" publicly, then on the open market. But it comes with some serious trade-offs. Well, not for Compass. On Compass.com, these listings can also appear without days-on-market counts or the history of price cuts. It means buyers have less of the full picture. You can't see if a property is struggling to sell, has been on the market for ages, and so on. For buyers, homes become harder to find when listings are scattered across private networks. And for sellers, ironically, the cost could be even higher.
Zillow and Compass both want you searching with them alone, and that fight has already spread to AI. In October 2025, Zillow put its listings inside ChatGPT. But AI companies play the same game. They want you to pick one model, and stay there. But, you don't have to. Models are all great at different things, search listings with ChatGPT, have Claude review the many PDFs and documents, get Gemini to organise your open houses in Google Sheets. But subscribing to lots of models can cost a fortune. So…. get all the best models under one subscription: Mammouth.
Mammouth gives you access to the best and cutting edge AI models in one place, for only $10 a month. Jump from GPT to Claude, or Gemini, within the same platform, for just $10. Yes, really. Switching from GPT to Mammouth could save you $120 a year, and you still get GPT, along with all the other major AI models. It's not just the chat function either, as you can use the specialized tools like Perplexity and Nano Banana. But it's not just better value, it's the best way to use AI. If you aren't satisfied with a response from ChatGPT, click "reprompt", and ask Claude, or Gemini, or Grok, or any other. Compare and challenge different AI models,
and get higher quality results overall. But it gets better. Use the Mammouth Agentic mode for more complex tasks, it can generate or edit documents, do in-depth web search, and take on multi-task queries. And just like the cutting edge AI platforms, there's Mammouth Code for developers, which integrates right into your native coding console. Mammouth currently equips more than 400 companies and public administrations with its dedicated plan. It has great plans for both individuals and companies. Stay at the cutting edge of AI without the lock in, and less of the cost. Click the url in the description and try Mammouth today. Thank you to Mammouth for sponsoring our videos.
A study of more than one million sales found that homes listed publicly sold for 17.5% more than comparable off-market homes. Why? Because a private listing reaches only one agency's clients. Public listings have more eyes, more buyers, more offers, and even bidding wars, which increase prices. So why would agents want this? Well, there's a pretty huge upside. According to Zillow's analysis of Compass data, which you should take with a grain of salt, private listings were 72% more likely to be "double-ended," meaning the same brokerage could collect commission from both the buyer and seller. And this phenomenon is
growing quickly. Five years ago, fewer than 1 in 5 sellers said their agent suggested going with a private listing. Now, it's almost 2 in 3. But Compass disagrees. As CEO Reffkin put it, "sellers will always have the freedom to choose how their listings are marketed and sold." All of this was bad news for Zillow. Very bad, but also potentially for both buyers and sellers. But, we need a bit more context behind these moves, and how Zillow might have, ironically, caused this. Because their intentions aren't noble either. Let's have a look at the strange legal battle between Zillow and Compass. Here, we have two business models that
can't coexist. Zillow wants every listing to be on Zillow. It's their whole premise, really. Buyers visit Zillow expecting to find every available home. And when someone inquires about a property, Zillow can turn that interest into a lead for a real estate agent. So, every missing listing is a potential buyer who might take their search, and eventual house sale, somewhere else. Zillow's own internal strategy documents described the risk of this "flywheel effect," in which its addressable market could shrink if other brokerages followed Compass's lead.
Meanwhile, Compass is doubling down on showing homes to its own clients first, before opening them up to everyone else. Compass also argues that public price histories and the number of days a home spends on the market can work against sellers. And to be fair, it does, but it's great for buyers is what I'd argue. Regardless, you have an open model, Zillow, and a closed model, Compass, but both want all the agents and listings. One of them had to give. And, Zillow decided to make the first move. In April 2025, Zillow updated its policy.
If you publicly market a house but don't make it available on Zillow within one business day, your listing could be banned from the platform. You'd get two warnings. "You're going to need to make a choice in how you want to market a listing." After this policy, at Compass, the share of its agents using the private-first strategy fell from 39% to 22% in just three months. That's a huge drop. Compass, naturally, was pretty unhappy about this. So, they sued. But with little evidence to prove that Zillow operated a monopoly,
in February, the judge refused to block Zillow's policy. At this point Zillow looked untouchable. But here's when Zillow did something. very ironic. Just weeks after this win, Zillow launched Zillow Preview, a product that let participating agencies showcase homes on Zillow before they reached the open market. Yes. Really. Many in the real estate world could not believe this. "It's bizzaro world to me that we're back in the same place again." "A sincere thank you to Zillow for offering homeowners more choice."
Still, Zillow defended this choice. Its argument was that Preview listings were visible to anyone browsing Zillow, while Compass's private exclusives were kept off the wider web. This is true, but many saw a different problem. Rather than letting Compass decide who sees a home first, Zillow wanted to control where buyers went to find it. Zillow wasn't against early access… It just was against early access that didn't run through Zillow. But Compass wasn't done. It changed its strategy. Compass dropped its lawsuit. Instead of fighting Zillow's rules directly, it went after something much more important: the supply of listings Zillow depends on. Remember Redfin? A major Zillow competitor,
it became a major outlet for Compass homes. But the bigger move came on April 24. Compass partnered with MRED, the massive Chicago-area database that local agents use to share property listings. A market where Compass handles roughly 35% of home sales. Under the deal, Compass would send MRED all its listings, including private exclusives, and pay for up to 100,000 agents to join the service. In return, MRED promised to protect participating agents from being "banned or penalized by third-party portals." Wonder which third party they're talking about.
Buried in this arrangement was a rule that could put Zillow's policy in a tough spot. MRED's licensing terms prohibit platforms from filtering listings based on which brokerage they come from. This would be disastrous for Zillow. So, they sued Compass back. Which led to a very strange chain of events, and how just 9 listings, caused tens of thousands to disappear. If you've watched this far, consider subscribing! It helps the channel and means you won't miss future videos. Zillow wasn't going to let this slide. They sued Compass and MRED, accusing them of working together to force Compass's private
listings onto Zillow. The lawsuit pointed to two statements in particular. MRED's CEO allegedly said she "was not backing down when it came to cutting off Zillow's listing feed." Meanwhile, Reffkin allegedly wrote that the "MLS must discipline Zillow for its new rules." Zillow argued that it was being forced into a corner to either abandon its listing policy or risk losing access to Chicago's massive property database. But suing didn't stop MRED. Remember, Compass had sent its private listings into MRED's database. Under MRED's rules, those homes counted as MRED listings, and Zillow couldn't simply pick which ones to
display. So MRED gave Zillow an ultimatum: display the nine listings that started private on Compass, which it had blocked under its new policy, by 11:59 p.m. on May 19, or lose access to every MRED listing. And to make things worse, none of those nine homes were even in Chicago. They were in California, Florida, and Georgia. Zillow refused. By the next morning, thousands of Zillow's Chicago listings disappeared. MRED accused Zillow of sacrificing access to 43,000 listings just to preserve its right to exclude nine homes. Meanwhile, on Zillow,
buyers and sellers were now facing a much worse housing market than they had the day before. Then the judge stepped in. He ordered MRED to restore Zillow's access while the case continued. But on one condition: Zillow had to display those nine Compass homes and could no longer enforce its ban in MRED's territory. The judge also barred Zillow from banning listings in ZIP codes nationwide where MRED had carried listings between April 2025 and April 2026. In a hearing in early July, Zillow's CFO warned that losing listings could trigger a "downward
spiral." Why? Well, fewer homes would attract fewer buyers, making Zillow less valuable to the agents who paid it for leads. Reffkin argued that homes left on the open market too long could "look like damaged goods." Reffkin also said that, according to Compass's internal data, pre-marketed homes sold for 2.9% more and went under contract 20% faster. So what happened? Well, fascinatingly, the judge acknowledged this would cause harm to Zillow… then denied their injunction. "Zillow has presented no evidence of any 'downward spiral'" in its business as a result of MRED's actions.
Zillow "has not sufficiently connected those injuries to a reduction in competition," and "transparency is not, standing alone, a goal of the antitrust laws." The judge, also, concluded that Zillow could avoid the damage by simply not enforcing its listing ban. Zillow now, is essentially forced to ignore its rule. And, things continue to get worse. for Zillow at least. Compass has signed similar deals with three more listing databases, including Bright MLS, the largest in the country. Nashville's Realtracs has already used that leverage, naming Zillow its only
non-compliant vendor. Now, Zillow might have put their control over the real estate market at risk. Zillow has lost roughly two-thirds of its market value, while Compass is now worth more. But Zillow's revenue grew 18% in the second quarter of 2026, and private listings still make up only around 1% to 2% of housing inventory. But the bigger loss is harder to measure. Zillow is losing control over the listings. It can't force people into not showing private listings elsewhere. But, I'm unsure if this outcome is good for buyers. With Compass, more homes could sit
behind brokerage gates, shown first to insiders and selected buyers. Senator Elizabeth Warren has warned of a "two-tiered housing market where insiders pay for exclusive access." But early access could increasingly happen through Zillow itself, via products like Preview. The housing market might have changed for good. Did you know that Zillow had an even bigger disaster, just a few years ago? Zillow tried to escape all this by buying houses itself. And it almost destroyed their entire business. Click this video for the rest of the story.