6:40
Looks like this criminal just ran out of luck. But maybe he's not a criminal at all. Let's take a closer look. Did you break this window? Yes, sir, but the baby was unresponsive. I couldn't get in the car. Do I have to pay for this window? Do you know if I have to pay for the window? Suspect is being apprehended and detained. You did good. We need more civilians like you. That was a close one, but it's not every day that the police are showing up to say you did the right thing. Today we're breaking down exactly what to do when
you find yourself in a sticky situation with the law, just like that one. While breaking a window is technically destruction of property, in situations involving a person or an animal trapped in a hot car, most states have a specific good Samaritan law that protect you from criminal charges and civil liability when responding to a real emergency necessity. The key things to remember. First, make sure the vehicle is actually locked. Second, the person inside needs to be in real distress. Third, and this is the most important one, call 911 before or immediately after you act. And finally, stay on the scene. Don't smash the window and just walk away. Stay there, cooperate, and
let the facts speak for themselves. Now, let's take a look at a scenario where that same police officer comes up behind you, but he's not there to tell you good job. Driver, turn off your engine and keep your hands on the steering wheel. You know why I'm pulling you over? Uh I did roll through that stop sign a bit earlier. I'm sorry, officer. And just like that, he confessed to a violation the officer hadn't even mentioned yet. Watch what the officer does with that. License and registration. Notice the officer didn't even respond to what the citizen said. He got what he needed and just moved on. And that's not an accident. And what happens next is
where most people make the biggest mistake. That's me. Mind if I take a look in your vehicle? I mean, sure. Yeah. Yeah, go ahead. And just like that, he handed over his Fourth Amendment rights with two words, go ahead. Once you consent to that search, anything they find is fair game. All right, would you step out of the vehicle for me? Wait. What did I do? And now the citizen is standing on the side of the road wondering, how did this happen? You know, pulled you over cuz your tail light was out. Let that sink in. This all started from a tail light, but the citizen volunteered that he ran a stop sign, which is a completely separate violation that the officer didn't even
know about. Then he consented to a search on top of that. One tail light stop turned into an arrest simply because of what came out of his mouth. Here's my card. You're going to need this. Let's try this again the right way. Any idea why I pulled you over? Remember, every word you say can either protect you or quietly build a case against you. I'm not sure, officer. Simple. He hasn't confessed to anything because he doesn't know why he was pulled over. License and registration.
Mind if I take a look in your vehicle real quick? Here's my card. You're going to need this. I don't consent to any searches, officer. This one's really important. If the officer asks, mind if I look, be careful on how you answer. Saying yes can be interpreted as yes, go ahead, and saying no can be interpreted as no, I don't mind. It's critical you don't leave any room for interpretation. Say it clearly and directly, just like the citizen did. I do not consent to any searches. You got something to hide?
No, sir. Look, am I being detained or am I free to go? That question right there, am I being detained or am I free to go, is one of the most powerful things to say during a traffic stop. Once the officer has finished what they pulled you over for, written a ticket, checked the license, run the plates, whatever it might be, the stop is technically supposed be over. You're free to go. That actually worked. Every time. Now that we know the police are always trying to build a case against you, let's move on to another common scenario where the police show up somewhere you feel completely safe, your own front door.
When you're out in the wilderness, you never know what you're going to eat. You going to get that? MREs. Hey, sorry to bother you. We just got a call from a neighbor, something about a altercation outside earlier today. You know anything about that? The police are never there to make small talk. Watch what happens when the citizen forgets that. Oh, yeah. I mean, that was nothing. He started it. He came into my property and he started getting into my face. I was just telling him to back off. So, there was a confrontation? I mean, yeah, but I didn't do anything. I JUST BOB He hasn't been accused of anything yet.
No charges mentioned. No arrest threaded. Just one open-ended question, and the citizen is already building the case against himself. The officers aren't interrupting him because they don't need to. He's doing all the work for them. Absolutely nothing like that would ever happen, ever, in a million years, Officer Jones and Officer Law Abiding Mike. Did it get physical? I put Okay, I pushed him, but only because he got in my face first. Just like that, he came to the door to defend himself and ended up confessing to a physical altercation on his own front porch. The officer hadn't accused him of anything, didn't mention any
charges, just asked, "Do you know anything about that?" And the citizen filled in every blank. The push, the argument, now it's all on record. This is one of the most common mistakes people make. The moment they feel accused of something, they panic and start explaining. Feels like the right thing to do, like if you just tell your side, it will all make sense and the officer will understand. But that officer isn't a judge. He can't clear you. He can only collect what you give them. We heard enough. You're under arrest. Now let's try that again, the right way. Look at that. This was definitely This is the police. Can you come to the door?
Everybody needs fire. You're going to get that? this five stars. Uh, can I help you? Hey, sorry to bother you. We just got a call from a neighbor, something about an altercation outside earlier today. I'm sorry, officer, but I can't answer any questions without my attorney present. Could you please just come out and talk to me? It'll only take a second. It's nothing serious. We just want to hear your side. Okay. Well, I'm not interested. Can you please open the door? This will only take a minute.
Am I being detained or am I free to go? And just like that, after asking, "Am I being detained?", the police have hit a wall, or in this case, a door. You're not detained. We just Okay. Well, not interested. Have a nice day. And in a he said, she said situation, the person that talks first and the most is usually the one that ends up in trouble. His job at that door was not to explain himself. It was to stay quiet, and he did exactly that. Oh, and if they ever claim they have a warrant, ask to see it before you open anything. A real warrant has to be presented. Don't take their word for it. One more thing,
notice they sent two officers. That's not just for safety, it's also a psychological tactic, good cop, bad cop. They're working together to make you feel like cooperation is your only option, when it definitely isn't. You might want to take this, too. K-pop demon hunters again? So, we've seen what happens in a traffic stop and at your front door. But, what about another situation where breaking the laws actually the right thing to do? I can't breathe. There's something wrong with my chest. [panting] I think I need to go to the hospital. Yes, I'm headed to Mercy General Hospital. I think my friend's having a heart attack. We don't have time to wait for an ambulance. I'm 3 minutes away.
She needs help right now. I think it's her heart. Are the police really pulling me over? Are you okay? Oh, no. I need help. I HEY, YOU DIDN'T PULL OVER BACK THERE. OFFICER, my passenger was having heart problems. I was on the phone with 911 the entire time. My hazards were on and I drove to the nearest emergency room. I wasn't going to stop and cost her those minutes. She could have died. I'm going to need your license and registration. Speeding is never automatically excused, but necessity, like saving a friend's life, is a legal defense that has protected people in this exact situation. And the reason the citizen is still
sitting here instead of being arrested comes down to three things. He kept his hazards on the entire time. He had 911 on the phone documenting the emergency in real time. And when the officer arrived, he stated the facts clearly without over explaining or making excuses. That combination is what makes the necessity defense work. One important thing to note though, it's still possible to get a speeding ticket here. Speeding is still against the law, so you may still have to appear in court and argue this defense to get it dismissed. This isn't a free pass. It's a legal argument and there's a big difference between the two. Sometimes the law is on your side, but what about
when you've done absolutely nothing wrong and the police still come after you? Yeah, that's what I said. She's tripping, for real. Yo, that's crazy. What happened? Hey, that's him right there. Let's go. STOP RIGHT THERE. DON'T MOVE. WHAT'S GOING ON? DROP WHAT'S IN YOUR HANDS. What the bleep? Keep your hands where I can see them. Me? I didn't do anything. You match the description of someone we're looking for in the area.
Suspect is being apprehended and detained. Is that the cops? Hello? Where were you coming from? I was just at the store. I'm heading home. I live two blocks from We got reports that someone THAT LOOKS JUST LIKE you robbing someone 10 minutes ago two streets over. That wasn't me. I've been at the store the whole time. Look, I have a receipt. I can show you. He's trying to prove his innocence on the sidewalk. It feels like the right move. It isn't. Watch what happens next. So, you were in the area? Well, yeah, but I wasn't Hands behind your back. You're being detained. Wait, what? I just told you. I didn't do anything. When he asked, "So, you were in the area?" That's actually a trained technique. The citizen said he was two
blocks away, and the officer immediately flipped it into something suspicious. It doesn't matter what the citizen said at that moment. It was going to be reframed against him regardless. Who else was with you at the store? Nobody. I was at the store. The cashier can tell you. You were alone? No witnesses? Two blocks from where this just happened? I SWEAR I didn't do anything. You can check the store cameras. We'll be deciding what we check. Right now, I need you to tell me exactly where you were and what you were doing for the last hour.
Okay. I left my apartment around 4:00. I went to the CVS on Main Street. I got some snacks. I got a drink. I went back on the street, and that's when I ran into you guys. He's completely innocent. Hasn't done anything wrong today, except walk down the wrong street at the wrong time. Now, he's in handcuffs. While it may seem extreme, it 100% could happen to anyone, including you. This is how fast a normal day becomes a legal nightmare. Some people end up in jail or even prison over this exact situation. Since 1989, the justice system has released over 3,000 people who were wrongfully convicted, collectively spending over 27,000 years behind bars
for crimes they didn't commit. And that's only the ones who were able to prove their innocence. Nobody knows the real numbers still behind bars today who don't deserve to be there. And the only response that can't be used against you is verbally invoking your Fifth Amendment right to remain silent. Let's see how that looks like. She's tripping, for real. STOP RIGHT THERE. DON'T MOVE. KEEP YOUR HANDS WHERE I CAN SEE THEM. YES, SIR. Drop what's in your hand. What's going on? Where are you coming from? I won't be answering any questions without my attorney present.
He's learning. He must have been watching my videos. We got reports of someone just like you robbing someone 10 minutes ago, two streets over. You want to explain that? Am I being detained or am I free to go? You're being detained while we investigate. You have anything to say for yourself? I invoke my right to remain silent. I want a lawyer, and I don't consent to any searches. This is the hardest part. He's standing in cuffs, completely innocent, saying nothing. Every instinct is telling him to explain himself, but he doesn't, and
that's exactly right. We're going to need your ID. It's in my back pocket. Hello. What's going on? Is that the cops? He didn't free himself by talking. The evidence is what cleared him, and the citizen didn't have to say a single word. You're free to go. His friend's voice on the cell phone, the sore camera, and the radio call. The truth came out on its own. Hello. Man, I'll tell you later. Because he didn't bury it under a panic statement that could have been twisted against him. Your goal in that moment is not to win the argument on the sidewalk.
It's to protect your rights and preserve the evidence. Stay calm, don't resist, and say clearly, "I'm invoking my right to remain silent. I want a lawyer, and I do not consent to any searches." Then stop talking completely. Let the truth do the rest. That call is a timestamp and a witness. It might be the thing that sets you free. I almost forgot. Thanks. Woo, close one. So, we've covered what to do on the street, but what about something you carry with you every single day, something with your entire life stored on it, that police are increasingly trying to get their hands on?
By this point, you probably understand that the best thing you can do in most situations is to stay silent. But, let's take a look at what happens when you find yourself a step further in the legal process. And this time, try to keep count of how many mistakes our friend makes here. I just want to have a conversation. Hear your side of things, you know? Okay. Mistake number one is already happening. He hasn't said a word yet, but he's about to. Even in an interrogation room, you have every right to remain silent until an attorney is present. He has no obligation to say anything. The second
the detective gives him a friendly look, he opens up. I'll be straight with you. Those guys out there, I'm buying your story. They think that you were involved with what happened earlier. I don't necessarily think that. So, I need you to help me help you. So, in your own words, tell me what you did earlier today. Look, I already told the other officers I was just walking back from the store. Mistake number two, help me help you is one of the oldest tactics in the book. The detective just told the citizen that he believes him, which is completely legal for police to do, even if they don't mean it. And it worked instantly.
Right. Look, I believe you, but Massage doesn't. Now, only way I can go back in there and get him to back off is that you give me something to work with. You understand? I mean, yeah, I guess. So, what's your story? From the beginning. Okay. Well, I left my apartment around 4:00. I went to the CVS on Main Street. I was there for about 15 minutes. Mistake number three, he already gave his exact story to the officers on the street. Now, he's giving it again in a recorded interrogation room. If anything is even slightly different between the two stories, like different
time, different details, anything, that inconsistency becomes ammunition for the prosecutor. Got it. And you were alone the whole time. Well, yeah, but I was on the phone with my friend. Mistake number four, by saying I was by myself, he just eliminated any corroborating witness before the detective even asked. Hey, actually, could I take a quick look at your phone, verify your call log, confirm your story? Should clear everything right up.
Um sure. Yeah. Here you go. Mistake number five, and this is a big one. He just handed over his phone voluntarily. There was no warrant and no legal obligation for him to do that. And according to the case Riley versus California, police need a search warrant to go through your phone unless you consent, which he just did. What's this? Wait, no. That was a joke. My friend and I, we watched a true crime documentary and we just got curious. I'm going to need you to stay right there. Wow, that was a rough one. Even after seeing what's on screen, he kept talking. That explanation is now on record and likely in a courtroom. It was a joke sounds exactly like what someone
would say when they get caught. Just like sarcasm doesn't work over text, jokes don't work in a courtroom. All they see is the words on the screen. Every single one of the mistakes he made came from the same root cause. He trusted the friendly detective and thought cooperating would make things better. And the room is designed to make you feel uncomfortable. The small table, the one door, all of it is designed to make cooperation feel like your only option. It isn't. The best thing you can do if you end up in that room is to sit back, stay quiet, and let your attorney do the talking, no matter how much you
feel you need to explain yourself. I'm trying to memorize these. Good, because the day you actually need them, you won't have time to look them up. We've covered what to do when the law works against you, but here's one final example of what it looks like when doing the right thing means breaking the rules. Hey, I heard something fall. Are you all right? Hey, you good in there? 911, what's your emergency? Yes, hi. I need an ambulance. I was walking past my neighbor's door and I heard a loud crash. I went and I knocked on the door, there's no response, nothing.
Okay, stay on the line. Do not force entry. Help is on the way. The dispatcher told him not to force entry. In most situations, follow that instruction. What do you mean it's going to be 45 minutes? We don't have 45 minutes. He's having a heart attack. But citizen smells something and genuinely believes this can't wait. Look, I smell gas. I'm going in and saving them. She's on the floor unconscious. Please hurry. Did you kick this door in?
Yes, sir. But I heard a crash. They weren't responding. I knew something was seriously wrong. I was on the phone with 911 the entire time. They can confirm everything. We need a medic. Let's be precise here because this one has a few layers. And I want to make sure you actually understand what protected the citizen legally because it might not be what you think. First, kicking in a door is not automatically protected just because you're trying to help. Good Samaritan laws exist in all 50 states, but what they mainly protect you from is getting sued from the person you helped. to need a statement from you. Of course, I'm not going anywhere.
We're going to get a statement from this guy. The kicked-in door is a separate issue entirely. That's where the necessity defense comes to play. If a reasonable person in that situation would genuinely believe that person needed immediate help, the law may justify entry. Second, did you notice the 911 dispatcher told the citizen not to force entry? In most situations, follow what 911 tells you. The citizen made a judgment call because he smelled something and believed lives were at risk. That judgment call, along with the phone call he made before acting, is what gives him a defensible position in court. And that brings us to the third
and most important point. The very first thing that citizen did before he touched the door was call 911. It documents that he identified a real emergency before anything happened. It creates a time stamp that puts him there for the right reason. Without that call, this is a much harder situation to defend. Call first, act only if you genuinely believe there's no other option. Stay on the scene and cooperate fully, and understand that the law may protect you, but it depends on the state, the circumstances, and the fact. When in doubt, the best thing you can do is wait for help. Kicking in someone's door can look like trespass, property damage, or even burglary if the police believe you went in for the wrong reasons. But, the
law recognizes that in genuine life or death emergencies, a reasonable person would act. What would you do in that situation? Now that we've seen scenarios where you can keep yourself protected, remember, don't answer questions without an attorney, don't consent to searches, and if you're ever unsure, asking, "Am I being detained or am I free to go?" will always be your best friend. I'm Law By Mike. Thanks for watching. Don't forget to like and subscribe if you enjoyed the video. See you next time.
