29:51
Nowhere in the West has sushi been pushed harder, priced higher, or copied faster than in New York City. While Los Angeles is the birthplace of sushi in the US, NYC is by far the largest, most lucrative, and most competitive market. There are more sushi restaurants in Michelin starred counters in Manhattan than anywhere else in the West. While in most American cities, sushi is defined by takeout rules or all you can eat, sushi in New York these days means omacas, fixed price, counter seating, reservations, and chef's choice. What was once fine dining luxury has evolved into a new mass market standard.
Omas here is no longer a 300,400 500 plus dollar experience. It's now 100 even $60 available at hundreds of spots across the city. These lowpric counters not only outnumber the traditional Michelin incumbents, but also compete head-to-head in the same prestigious neighborhoods. Today, there are about two omocases for every three sushi restaurants in New York City. It's one of the fastest growing categories of the past 5 years, and every month a new spot emerges, pushing the price down even further.
Omas, which means chef's choice in Japanese, is nothing new. Sushi restaurants in the US have offered it for generations as a line item buried in a wide menu. But what's new is Omacas as the entire business and as a standalone restaurant built for nothing else. Their menus are rigid and their prices are fixed. Everyone gets the same 12 to 20 courses where the only real choice is how many. All car ordering is rare and if it exists, it's always tacked on at the very end. There are no walk-ins, no takeout, and no delivery. Most courses are raw or served warm. Seating is by reservation with strict start times and durations. And every one of these shops runs just a handful of fixed seings for dinner and
rarely bother with a lunch service. Unlike traditional restaurants which live or die based on location and foot traffic, these omocas are true digital destinations. They run out of cheap tiny hidden spaces in back streets, basement, second floors, or alleyways. Their kitchens have no fryers or stoves, and they can only seat maybe 10 to 20 people at most at a time. And there are only ever one or two servers as the chef preps, serves, and clears every course for each guest. What Omas's lack in capacity and visibility, they make up for in ruthless efficiency. Throw in an inherently aesthetic, social media friendly product, and you get a future
proof business built for the modern age with an answer for every pressure that breaks a normal restaurant like rent, labor, marketing, and margin. In New York City, these costs are at their most extreme. In a time where every category is stagnating, omicas here are booming with their modern unorthodox digital first business model. Ultimately, NYC is an accelerated market and what emerges here shapes the future of sushi in urban America where Omas may very well become the dominant format. To understand this market change at a macro level, we scraped over 400,000 sushi restaurants across six cities and verified each by hand. when they opened, their price point, how many shut
down, and their business model. To build the first accurate snapshot of the American sushi industry. And to capture the micro, we go boots on the ground across New York City, and go behind the counter with three owners who each bet on completely different strategies and price points. $80 for the Grom Witch Village and Midtown Millennials, $125 for working professionals in Soho, and $250 for the celebrities in Tribeca. to discover what it really takes to win in the omocas business. My is just one out of 24 omocas in Soho and one out of 10 in a threeb block radius. Upstairs, Shawn puts the final touches on tonight's service while Solomon breaks the fish down in the basement. The two owners are a clean
example of the independent rests fueling the city's omicass boom. Shawn runs the front. Solomon commands the back. And together they divide and conquer. With just 11 seats and a single counter, my is the quintessential modern New York Omacas. Invisible from the outside, but lean, high margin, and exceptionally efficient on the inside. And at $125 ahead, they sit at the perfect midpoint for the neighborhood. This current market shift has been decades in the making. While Los Angeles was the birthplace of sushi in the US, New York became the flashier and more visible proving ground where the category evolved the furthest. From the 1980s to early 2000s, sushi in Manhattan was rarely a standalone business. 90% of the restaurants
serving it were broad Japanese or Asian fusion spots. Americans came for noodles, teriyak, or tempura, and sushi was just one line item on the menu. For even New Yorkers, raw fish back then was still a hurdle. As a result, most Japanese restaurants stayed generalists out of necessity with sushi as a side item rather than as the main event. The few that did specialize were all clustered in Midtown around the very skyscrapers where Japanese banks, automakers, and conglomerates had open offices in the8s. These early counters lowered the barrier further by offering sushi in flexible combinations and alakart, which in turn made them ideal venues for corporate dinners between American and Japanese businessmen. So while omas remained a
foreign concept, these places popularized sushi as a standalone meal and established a cultural standard that still holds today. Then from 2004 to 2014, New York elevated sushi to unprecedented levels of recognition, luxury, and prestige. The traditionally lowprofile minimalist Japanese omicas was thrust into the global spotlight and rebranded as a glitzy, critically acclaimed fine dining experience with record-breaking prices that surpassed even Japan. Over this decade, the sushi category would be permanently fractured into extremes in pricing and format. In 2004, Masa opened in Midtown and singularly legitimized Omicas as a high-end format and viable business model. Masa imposed standards never before seen in the US with fish airship from Japan, a six-f figureure
wood counter that needed to be sanded daily, and no menu, no choices, and no alle cart. Omas was the only option, and you ate whatever was set in front of you. With just 26 chairs, seats needed to be booked weeks in advance. At $300 per person before drinks, tax, and tip, Masa became the single most expensive restaurant, not just in New York, but in the entire world. It reframed omicas from a niche menu item to an exclusive exacting craft and pushed that this was the way that sushi was meant to be eaten. In 2009, Masa became the first sushi restaurant in America to earn three Michelin stars and would remain the only one for the next decade. Today, Masa still remains the single most expensive restaurant in the world at $950
per person. While the rest of the country pushed towards accessibility, repackaging sushi into rolls and boxes at grocery stores, food courts, malls, and neighborhood takeout, Masa had run in the opposite direction. And its success inspired others. Morioto brought a star power from Nou and Iron Chef to open a 200 seat restaurant in Manhattan, further cementing New York City as a destination for top tier sushi, whether traditional or fusion. Then in 2011, the acclaimed Jirro Dreams of Sushi captivated Americans further, chronicling the life of an 85-year-old three Michelin star Tokyo sushi master and established Omicas in the public eye as a fine dining experience defined by the chef behind the counter.
Writing the documentaries momentum, Sushi Nakazawa opened in 2013. And where Masa had broken the sushi market upward, Nakazawa broke it downward. With a 21 course omicas from Jurro's own apprentice at just $150 per person, Nakazawa disrupted the high-end market by proving that worldclass sushi could be delivered at scale and at a fraction of the cost. It legitimized Omicas as a mass market business where meals could be quarterly rather than a once-in-a-lifetime experience. With 35 seats and multiple turns, Nakazawa served close to 100 people every night, achieving volume and margin at a far lower price. With Masa as the ceiling and Nakazawa as the floor, high-end omas began opening across the city and pricing themselves in between
these two giants. By 2015, New York City had nearly twice as many sushi restaurants as it had two decades earlier. There were now 12 of these Omicas only spots in NYC, but they were still the market minority, accounting for less than 10% of the city's sushi restaurants. The imitators tried to replicate Masa's playbook, but without his Michelin stars, brand power, or backing, there wasn't enough wealth at the top to keep everyone alive. 50% of all Omicas opened in this era would shut down. Meanwhile, only 8% of the nonomac sushi restaurants closed as they survived on volume, accessibility, and value. just as a very different wave was about to hit. It was in this era when Shawn and Solomon entered the market.
Shawn worked his way up at Morioimoto, Tao, Mumu Fuku, and Catch, which were all local powerhouses riding the same raw fish boom. Tao made sushi the centerpiece of a nightclub, and Catch priced it like steak. It was at Catch that Shawn met Solomon, and over the next 10 years, the two friends pulled funds and honed ideas until they finally opened Mory in 2024. But the market today looks nothing like the one they entered. There are now six times as many omocas as there were in 2014. And it's not just the density that's changed, but also the price. Nakazawa's $150 was a huge shock back in 2013. The average cost of an omas in New York City has drifted below that floor despite over a decade
of inflation. Oh, I can get you guys whenever now. Right this way, guys. In this neighborhood alone, there's maybe 10 or 15 if you just open Google Maps. But again, it's different price points, right? People want to pay for certain things for $65 for $125 and people are comfortable paying $400, you know? So, we're right in that comfortable $125 range where in this neighborhood it's very standard. There's those, you know, $60 $70 ones where you get maybe 12 to 14 degree or courses. Often times personally I feel like I leave hungry or you have you know 125 which where we're at which has 17 to 18 courses. We are doing upgrades this evening. We have an uni that you can add to the tun.
We also have a caviar you can add to what would be in place of your handle. Mor's product market fit comes from breaking away from the tradition that everyone else still clings to in this saturated market. When every Omicas claims that they use the freshest fish and the most traditional methods, none of it means anything. Even though Solomon has been a sushi chef for 12 years and Shawn in the business for 10, neither carries the pedigree and ethnicity required for the top of the market. Solomon is Indonesian Chinese and Shawn is Taiwanese. Neither trained in Japan or apprentice under a famous Shokunin. Rather than competing on frontiers they'd never win, the pair have chosen to trade away the lineage and luxury arms race for a
return to basics. They've turned their lack of pedigree into a creative license to do things with product and space that no traditional omocas ever could. A lot of places just do niries, maybe one hand roll or two to kind of top it off. But I think it kind of gets lost. You don't remember which one you had or what was your favorite. It was all just, you know, fish over rice with sauce in the most pleasant way possible. I love sushi. For us here at Mory, you want to make sure it's beyond that. We have five appetizers, five ningiris, and five hand rolls. And we create actual more memorable experiences
in terms of presentation of the food to you know the service style and to of course like the flavors and all the prep that starts from the chefs in the morning. Some fish are dryaged, some are salt cured, some are marinated, some fish is cold smoked. A lot of omocas is very common. You walk in and it's brightly lit, cheaper wood looking. Many times they all look the same or feel the same. And then obviously you have ranges where some are super quiet and then you know the chef's just cutting and you're not sure if you should speak or not. You should just watch or you know nod your head. What we try to do here is you know dark intimate kind of atmosphere that ambiance to really feel like you're in an upscale environment. All
the spotlighting along the walls. All of these accents highlight the plate area for each of the appetizers in the courses to kind of make sure at the end of the day the food is the show. I always tell the chefs it can't be just fish over rice cuz everyone can serve that and we don't worry about anybody else. That's why no one's name is on my not Seaun's, not Solomon's, not anyone's. Freed from the authenticity contest, they treat tradition as a guide but not an obligation. By stripping away everything that makes high-end omic acid, Mory widens the door. The format stays intact.
Every course is still served by hand to every guest, but the chef is not meant to be revered. Their assembly is not the entire show and the meal is not a mandatory performance to sit through in silence. The show is the food and the guests rather than who or what is behind the counter. Mor space is tiny with just 400 square ft upstairs and another 400 in the basement. Their entire operation is smaller than a subway. A footprint this small is unusable for most businesses as a normal restaurant would have to choose between seats or a working kitchen. There's just no room for both. Without seats and dining in traffic, a space like this is really only usable by high turnover grab-and-go concepts like ice
cream shops, bakeries, coffee windows, or pizza counters. Yet, Omacas erases this trade-off entirely because all the food is prepped and portioned downstairs. The upstairs doesn't need a working kitchen. A few underounter fridges, some warmers, standing space for each chef, and the restaurant is set for service. The ability to maximize sales in spaces that almost no other tenant can is how omocas fundamentally thrive. My pays just $7,500 a month for rent and at $112 a square foot, that's 75% cheaper than the Soho average. They're in a prime neighborhood at a quarter of the going rate. With advanced bookings, omacas get to control food and labor costs in ways that most restaurants can't without having to sacrifice product or service. Because the room is
sold by reservation, Mory knows its revenue before the night begins and before the first guest ever sits down. In contrast, traditional restaurants fly blind. They don't know how many people will come, what they'll order, or how much they'll spend until the night is over. So, they must staff and prep for a crowd that may never show. Omacas, like my opposite. They scale their teams and prep work up or down to match the guests that are on the books. If the 530 is fully booked like it is today, it's all hands- on deck. If the 7:30 comes in light, the staff thins out. And if the 9:30 is empty, everyone goes home early. The traditional restaurant has a stock of full pantry and take the loss on whatever doesn't sell in time. An omocas flips
this conundrum as the menu bends to the inventory rather than the other way around. If Mory has too much of one ingredient, too little of another, or gets a special deal from its suppliers on something else, it can rework its courses up to the day of to maximize inventory and margins without the guest ever knowing. Predictability enables precision, precision enables efficiency, and efficiency enables profit. It's all about timing. In larger scale restaurants, you do well and you bring in the sales, but the reality is you had a big prep team in the morning. had, you know, all these extra layers of labor and overhead expenses that are necessary just for a certain amount of income that comes in. On a busiest Friday night, Saturday
nights, we have two chefs, one server and a porter. And that's the maximum that we'll need to operate efficiently. I've worked and managed at places, you know, we do 500 to,000 people a night versus here, the max we can do is uh 33 to 36. Starting small is always at least a safer way to go. I'd love it to be, you know, 100 seat place, of course, but then all the added pressure comes with trying to fill 100 seats multiple turns every night. For us, like I said, 11 seats. If I can't fill it, then I'm in the wrong business. Yet, the greatest advantage behind the Omas business model is not labor or product, but instead buildout. Starting an omas is orders of magnitude cheaper than virtually any other restaurant. And this low bar is the real
engine behind their rapid saturation across New York City. Any restaurant that uses a gas range, fryer, or an open flame legally needs a type one hood before it can open. In Manhattan, this single requirement costs six figures alone. It involves steel duck work punched through multiple stories of century old brricked, fire sprinkler systems, and months of permitting. Omacases get to bypass all this regulation. They have no friars, no stoves, no flames, and no gas lines. Everything is steamed. The blowtorrches count as handheld tools, not appliances. And with under a dozen seats, Mory stays below the occupancy thresholds that would otherwise require them to have multiple fire exits and separate ADA bathrooms. Under this
lens, Omicas are regulatory arbitrage. They don't just make better use of small spaces, they get to operate in spaces that no other restaurant can. The rules that cost everyone else hundreds of thousands of dollars and months of buildout don't apply. Mory pushes efficiency even further by pre-slicing the fish downstairs before service so courses can come out on time with fewer hands. My success in 2 years and 400 square ft comes from being what the market isn't. They're not bound to authenticity but they're also not trying to escape it either. The concept is loose enough to feel like a night out yet rigorous enough to still deliver the fixedric multi-course experience that people expect from the word omicas. We brand
ourselves as a contemporary omocas which is a very broad generic term but I think that's also the beauty of it. There's no set definition of how things should be done. I think that takes away from the creativity of just serving food and cuisine in general. At the end of the day, what's most important are the flavors and the textures that we create on top of everything else that adds to the full experience. Everyone has their budgets and you always start low and hopefully keep moving up the ladder, right? So, I used to eat, you know, and try different places, 60, 70, 80 bucks. We're at that sweet spot. I feel like for 125 where it's not too expensive, but we're not cheap either.
We have multiple signature dishes that are always here that people continue to rave about, always come back for, then you want to keep it like that. My grosses on average $84,000 a month for an annual run rate of $1.01 million. Their operating margin sits at 22%. With the ownership split, Solomon and Shawn are likely taking home no more than 5 figures each every year. But being in the black so early on is an achievement in itself, especially for firsttime restaurant tours. Shawn and Solomon are ultimately not the only ones with this perspective. One in threeas in the city today fall in this $100 to $200 price
range. Yet, the market looks very different for those at the top where the pressure is the greatest. Amasa or a Morioimoto can charge whatever it wants and still fill every seat by name alone. Yet those without that acclaim and fame can't. It's increasingly harder for premium omicas to justify their higher prices and to prove what they actually do better than the flood of cheaper, less rigorous and less sophisticated options below them. For owners who have committed years of their lives to this craft, their outlook is far less optimistic. This is the world that Jay sees as the owner and Taiisho of Tsubame. a $250 in Tribeca that has served world-class athletes, celebrities, and movie stars
for the past three years. Every case study on modern MBA starts from the same place. Hard data, and factf finding across dozens of spreadsheets, financials, and transcripts. We've been openly skeptical of AI and refuse to let it do any of our analysis, writing, and thinking. We let our own crunching and instinct develop original, grounded, and intellectually rigorous thesis. That's why we've kept every AI tool at arms length until now. Where we struggle is ingesting mountains of data and synthesizing the insight and complexity to a broad audience. It takes hours to find what matters before we've written a line. That's where today's sponsor, Superhum, comes in. Superhum, from the makers of Grammarly, is more
than just an AI chatbot. It's your AI partner that works inside the apps and websites you already use, proactively making suggestions to improve your work. Let us show you. First, we turn on superhuman within our Grammarly browser extension. Once it's on, it reads whatever page we're working on. With a 10K open, we can ask it to summarize the page or pull the takeaways and get oriented in these hundreds of pages in seconds. Instead of skimming for 20 minutes, we can ask what it says about something specific like CEO remarks and it surfaces exactly that. and we still get to dive in and verify every detail
ourselves. What won us over is that it's right there inside the page, not in a separate chatbot that we have to copy, prompt, and paste back from. Superhum shows up where the work already is. Another agent that blew us away is reader reactions. It predicts the takeaways, questions, and points of confusion a reader may have with what we've written and suggest revisions to make it land. It shows where a reader might get lost or push back. And it's all suggestive and advisory where nothing gets pasted in blind. Try Superhum from the makers of Grammarly using our link in the description or by scanning the QR code above. Thank you to Superhum for supporting Modern MBA and making this episode possible.
Christian, the Chawamushi is done. You can take it out. So, did you take a look at the menu today? Yeah. So, on the menu, everything is the same as last week. Only thing that's different is the Yakimono. It's going to be the muki otate. No celebrations, right? No celebrations and no allergies. Before you start service, just make sure you know all the windows, doors, everything is wrapped up. Like the omocas in Japan, Tubame is a one-man show. Jay designs the menu, picks the ingredients, preps every course, slices every fish, and serves every guest by hand. He's worked in restaurants for 30 years, has run three
omocas in New York City for the last 10, and has seen this market change dramatically in the past five. Sububame's menu runs deep in seasonality and luxury with starter courses made from red king crab and hokaido uni to soup made from matsusake, one of the world's most expensive mushrooms only available in the fall. Yet for Jay, luxury doesn't make an omakas. Anyone can buy expensive ingredients. What matters is what the chef does with them to make them more than just expensive fish on rice. At Sububame, he pushes new ideas and fuses history with cuisine, but never strays far from tradition. I started getting into fine dining. I kind of learned a lot of standards and what it means to be a very high-end chef. You know, what it means
to work with a passion instead of just work for a paycheck. My style is Kai style. Alicaz customer when they come over here what they enjoy is they're not just getting all raw dishes to start. Sometime I serve like a tempora dish sometime I serve like a yaktori dish. So they get a variation of what Japanese cuisine is not just one element. Back in the Edeto period sushi essentially started out as peasant food. They were serving large piece of rice. It's kind of like on the giri almost with small piece of fish. But it wasn't until the royalty got a hang of it. They wanted more protein, less rice, and slowly kind of evolved into what you have nowadays.
There wasn't no tuna and there was no salmon. There wasn't like hamachi stuff that you see nowadays because there was no refrigeration. So only fish they were serving as fish with a lot of omega-3 or fish oil content. They're able to cure salt, pickle, vinegar, so they could last throughout the day without spoiling. Kohada is one of the very original sushi pieces. You know, even for today's menu, I still serve kohada. is the same way as it is served in the 1700. Back in the days, you know, fatty tuna was essentially like a throwaway piece cuz Japanese diet doesn't really consist of a high fat. But it wasn't until it got very popular western industry that people wanted the most oily fish, you know, with a lot of
fat, a lot of flavor profile. So slowly, you know, Toro blue fence started be becoming like a very key piece to like a Japanese omocaz, you know, and I use it. I enjoy it, but I want to showcase other ingredients that's not typical available. I want to focus on a little bit more traditional instead of using very expensive ingredients to make the menu look high-end using like fua, wagyu, toro, uni, caviar, gold flakes, whatnot. You know, Sububame is Jay's third omas. And while it's serious, traditional, and high-end, he didn't start out that way. From 2015 to 2019, a cohort of American concepts took the Nakazawa formula and pushed it even further, bringing down price, catering to the mass market directly and
disrupting the high-end omicasses above them. Jay's restaurant was one of these. At the time, sushi in New York was effectively split between the 300 plus Michelin Stardo Macas and the $15 neighborhood takeout with Nakazawa as the medium in between. The two biggest name in this new era attack the market from an even lower price point. Sugarfish was born out of the legendary LA sushi bar Sushi Noa, where Japan born and Japan trained Kazunori Nozzawa imposed strict rules on Hollywood elites like no phones and no loud talking. Sugarfish was his fast casual spin-off where he repackaged the same precision of his acclaimed sushi into 40 and $60 set menus for dining in and takeout.
Sugarfish reached Manhattan in 2016 and while it wasn't an omic acved you could scale the philosophy and rigor of one for the masses at a fraction of the cost of Nakazawa. Then there was Sushian Jones, David Buhadana's tiny stand in the Bowerery. As a self-taught American chef, he served a 30inut 12-piece omic acu for just $50 per person. With only four seats and a strict 30inut seating, Sushian Jones cranked through guests. Between them, they redefined what omocases could cost and how fast it could move. But most importantly, they proved that great sushi didn't have to be expensive or be prepared by a classically trained Japanese master. It could come from an outsider. Jay opened
his first omocas in 2015, a year before Sugarfish and Sushi on Jones. He leaned into his status as an outsider, naming it Gajjun, as neither he nor his sushi partner were classically trained. Queens was a safe proving ground. As a burrow with no other omocas, they could hone their craft without going head-to-head with the Japanese in Manhattan. Jay prices at the tiers of $45, $65, and $125 to make up for the location and leaned into fusion to sidestep authenticity. The two of them served creative pieces like hamachi with banana pepper or smoked almonds on tuna to compete on value and vibes. Under this lens, Jay in 2015 was essentially running Mory's playbook before my existed and at the
exact same price point. He was one of the pioneers who proved the model and helped spark the wave of affordable omocas that saturate the city today. But Gajin success didn't last as a partnership. When his friend left to pursue his own ventures, Jay refocused on his fine dining roots, maturing away from toppings and gimmicks and towards quality, technique, and tradition. He rebranded Gaiene as Coyo in 2019. But months later, the pandemic had shut everything down. The success of Sugarfish, Sushian Jones, Gai, and other cheap local landmarks paved the way for the present-day boom. The investors and sushi chefs working inside all these concepts all arrived at the same conclusion. A lower-end omic
acer bet than a higher-end one, but also far more lucrative than a conventional sushi restaurant. In just 5 years, Manhattan has added around 120 new omocas, nearly five times the number of the era before. Omicas today make up nearly half of all sushi restaurants in the city. This rapid saturation has led to commoditization as the median price of omocas have fallen even further to $100. As cheap omocas flooded the market during co jay chose to spend the next 5 years studying, developing and training. And he watched as the affordable format that he had helped pioneer get cheapened into unrecognizable lows. Many of these new low-end spots have jumped the shark with offerings like all you can eat, bottomless sake, buy 1 get one
free, unlimited Wagyu, or salmon nigiri. All still build and sold as omicas for $50, $60, $70. And where the draw is eating as much as you can in one sitting in form and volume, they have nothing to do with what omocas means in word and tradition, yet still sell themselves as one under the guise of approachability. And the market laps it up. Today, four out of every five omocas cost under $200, and they outnumber the high-end cohort by over three to one. Jay had built his career at the low end, but never expected it to become the default in Manhattan. If we look at the failure rates of all omocas ever opened in New York City, less than 5% of the spots under $100 have shut down. The next tier up hovers at 10%. But if we keep going up,
the closure rates climb until we reach the $200 to $300 range where more than one in five shut down. These omocasis carry the intensive labor and premium ingredients of the elite. But without the critical acclaim, they're easily undercut by new competition who claim to offer the same for much less. And they're also not famous enough to win over the connoisseurs. This is the price range of where Sububame lives. At $250, 10 seats, and no Michelin star, Jay operates at the single most dangerous price point in the city, and he feels it every day. After the pidemic ended, all of a sudden all these lower endocaz started popping up to fill in the gap. And there hasn't been really much of a training aspect for omocaz. It typically take a
lot of years of expertise, dedication, learning what fish is in season, how to take care of fish, how to cure them, salt them, pickling them to use as a proper omocazin menu. I seeing hamachi sushi with jalapeno, but that's like hamachi jalapeno on all these sushi spot. Even like salmon with cream cheese or cheese. It's essentially it's the same thing as they're paying maybe $20 a person, but they're able to sell it for 50 in format. You know, you see a lot of like frozen unagi, frozen scallop, frozen shrimps, but it's all coin as fresh, you know, but it's not the case cuz you cannot get something that's very fresh and expensive and still serve it for $50 and still make a profit. And at
the same time, you know, it does give people a perspective. You know, Kaz is certain way, which is not the biggest thing about Kaz is like you're enjoying what the chef creates for you. is not just, you know, having some guy that been doing supermarket sushi for a certain amount of time and just put everything together format and call it. As a result, while everyone else raced down, Jay grew up. Today, now 40 years old, he's traded gimmicks for restraint, novelty for technique, and shortcuts for mastery, going deep into the history and discipline that he had once skipped over as an improvisational outsider. He had also learned something about partners. From Chicago to Gai, every shared venture he had was a negotiation split two ways.
Sububame is the opposite. As Jay's first fully owned and operated restaurant, where every decision, investment, standard, and detail runs through him, not out of ego, but as a full expression of his skill and vision. He chose to build it in Tribeca, the most expensive neighborhood in New York. He converted this abandoned jewelry store across the Four Seasons into this 10-seat counter. And Tribeca is one of the last corners of the city that Jay believes still values across as a craft rather than a routine to be rushed and diluted. I change my menu once a month, you know, to reflect the change of season. So even though I work 5 days a week, I spend all day just doing menu development and
I could get to taste what I want to use, what ingredient that's coming in season. This some ingredient might be coming in season, but it might not taste as good this season than last season. And so I might have to wait a little bit before I start serving it instead of just watering stuff off my vendor and expect it to taste great. The chef aspect of omocaz is important. I think if you lose the chef aspect to Kaz, you kind of lose the identity to Kaz, you know. Subame grosses on average $90,000 a month for an annual run rate of $1.1 million. While Mory runs three seedings a night at 2 hours each, Jay only runs two seedings at 2 and 1/2 hours a piece.
His courses aren't entirely pre-plated and assembled like Mory's, but instead cooked to order. At $250 ahead, no guest wants to feel rushed, and Jay physically can't add a third seating without the fatigue showing in his staff and food. Sububame's operating margin sits at 15% and would likely be even lower if Jay ever paid himself an hourly wage. His ingredient and payroll costs are higher simply because his staff are all seasoned fine dining professionals. Under this lens, tie shows are like the Texas barbecue pit masters we've covered before. They're all owner operators who pour their lives into their craft and the real cost of that. The time, the focus, and dedication to show up every
single day far exceeds the hard costs that show up in the numbers. Jay feels the burnout. He has a wife and kids, and he's begun to wonder if he should step away into consulting or move somewhere less saturated. Spending his days off testing ingredients instead of being with his family is an imbalance that he knows can't last forever. He funded every penny of Sububame himself without a single outside investor. And he's worked his way up from Queens to Tribeca. Sububame is the inverse of Mori. Mory is Omicas as a format and opportunity faceless, efficient, accessible, decentralized, and serviceable. Sububame is omicas as a craft where everything is by tradition concentrated on a single person where labor never lets up and where everything
has to be the best every time all the time. Omas is Jay's career but it's also a cage no different than how it is for Jirro and his sons in Tokyo as the price of insisting every single day on the very best. When I built this restaurant, I wanted to be focused on my cuisine, on my style. But I feel like it's the same thing as Japan. When people come in here, you know, and they have they come in for the chef. So for me to be able to serve what I want to the guests, I had to prepare everything myself like the butchering the fish, the curing of the fish, making of the soup, all the sauces, anything that takes a little bit more uh technique driven, I want to do it myself. I still play everything
myself. Even though it's a lot of work, but I think when customer come here and they kind of see the passion in it. Nowadays, you see a lot of high-end Omicazi restaurant, they might have their name on it, but they might have other chef they train, take their lead, but when people go in there, you know, and they're expecting the chef to serve you, but he's not there. You don't know if his style is going to be different than the chef that he trained, you know, but that's what you're paying for, you know. So, if the guest is paying to come to see me eat my food, I feel like I should be doing everything for them. The reality is that the omocases that are thriving today are the ones at the low
end with greater audiences, replicable playbooks, simpler menus, and prices under $100. They scale and expand faster than the Mores and Sububame of the world. With more chairs, more seings, and shorter meals, these spots push volume unlike anyone else. They take walk-ins on top of reservations and offer delivery and takeout to capture the mass market, budgetconscious casual diner. The labor is never concentrated on one or two people, but spread across multiple chefs and shifts. The product is simpler, the service is bare bones, and the demands on staff and ingredients are much lower. All of which only strengthens the efficiencies of the Omacas model. This is the world of
Yoshi, who runs Sushi Kai in the West Village and East Village. He's just opened a third location in Midtown under a different name, but with the same menu, playbook, and at a slightly lower price. At just $85 per person for 16 courses, Sushi Kai is one of the city's biggest and most popular entry-level omic aces. It's here where product has been boiled down to its most scalable, fast, casual, and essential form as fish on rice in the form of nigiri or hand rolls. There is no soup, no appetizer, and no dessert. Guests are reminded of their 75minute meal limit before they even sit down, and they get served a new course roughly every 5 minutes. The chefs move straight from one piece to the next. Before all this,
Yoshi worked at Nakazawa for 8 years, long enough to see firsthand how effective the model could be and how much room there was left for new entrance. For Yoshi, $85 was never about undercutting anyone. Instead, it was the price point where they felt that they could consistently fill seats without deviating away from the ingredient quality, prep, and standards that they had absorbed directly from Nakazawa. And with just six seats in their first shop in the East Village, they didn't have the runway to risk on ultra premium ingredients, experiment freely, or chase stars at the top of the market. Thus, like any fast casual concept, Sushi Kai's menu is optimized for customers as a fixed lineup where only one or two
pieces change a quarter. The menu is basically a greatest hits of all the viral crowd-pleasing fatty fish and rich meats that Americans recognize and crave like A5 Wagyu, Hokkaido uni, caviar, fatty tuna, and fuagra served the same way every single night. And so, while a true omocas is about letting the chef decide what's freshest, sushi kai in contrast can't. Not if it wants to fill every seat and hold its price point. and free culture wasabi shellfish meat. Fore Under this lens, Sushi Kai thrives in serving the specific pieces that Americans want most. Rather than reinventing the menu every month, they strip out everything else. The meticulous plating, the laborious prep, the complicated techniques, the strict
ambiance, the overbearing etiquette, the rigid reservations, and the long meal times. These are all the things that make traditional omocas expensive in the first place. The result is a casual space where people can walk in, talk, drink, eat, and leave with all their bucket list pieces for a fraction of the price and time that it would cost them anywhere else. But at the sub$und00 price point, he faces the greatest saturation. Sushi Kai's volume of competition is twice that of Morice and seven times that of Sububame. Today, one in every two new Omicas in the city price themselves below $100.
Yoshi is the first to admit that he's frustrated. Sushi Kai has been caught in a race to the bottom and one that he ironically helped popularize. They've raised prices themselves every year, even as new entrance drag down the broader market. And like Jay, he's no fan of what's happening. for Ultimately, Sushi Kai's greatest obstacle is talent rather than product or competition. Reliable, consistent sushi chefs are the one thing he can't systematize. And in this booming market, they can leave before anywhere. A decent sushi chef in New York City costs $300 a day. Yoshi's turned down investors because scaling only makes quality
harder to hold. And as he's already found across three locations, upholding standards only gets more and more difficult with every additional seat and every new pair of hands. Sushi Kai today grosses $85,000 a month per location for an annual run rate of $1.02 million. At three locations at capacity, that's $3 million gross across Yoshi and his three brothers. And unlike Jay, the scalability of this model has kept his burnout manageable. Things have only gotten bigger. The original sushi kive 6 years ago in the east village had only eight seats. The second in West Village grew to 16 and the third in Midtown now seats 20. As a fast casual operation, they lean hard into modern marketing. With social media and
influencers, which is a lane that Mory only dabbles in, and Sububame rarely touches. Sushi Kai's average operating margin sits at 20%. In the end, all three spots are running from the same thing. Mori, Sububame, and Sushi Kai look nothing alike. A faceless counter in Soho, a one-man army in Tribeca, and a fast casual chain spreading across Manhattan. But the pressures they face in a saturated market are identical. When there's an omocas on every block, when everyone's fish comes from the same market in Tokyo, and when the price keeps on dropping, you have to decide what you're really selling. Shawn and Solomon sell an experience, Yoshi sells the hits, and Jay sells himself. The paradox is that everything
that makes Omicas such a good business is exactly the same thing that makes it so easy to replicate. The low bar that enabled Shawn, Solomon, Jay, and Yoshi to grow from employees to owners is the same low bar that lets thousands of others in with far less skill and experience. It took Sushi 40 years to climb from a cheap add-on to a $950 seat at Masa. And it's only taken 5 years for Omicas to become the new default and the normal way to eat sushi in the world's most expensive city. Whether it's labeled as democratization or saturation, it ultimately doesn't matter. It's not slowing down and it's not staying in New York. The only thing left to find out is how cheap it gets before the word doesn't mean much of anything.
